Tixier D, Levy C, Le Bourgeois J P, Léandri J, Loisance D
Centre de Recherches Chirurgicales, CNRS URA 1431, Université Paris-XII, Créteil.
Presse Med. 1992 Dec 2;21(41):1941-4.
The use of discordant xenografts may solve some of donor shortage problems. The beneficial effects of treatment with total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) and classical drugs on this discordant model of transplantation rejection was evaluated. Twenty-four lamb hearts were transplanted heterotopically in the abdomen of 24 pigs. Group I received no treatment (control). Group II received continuous intravenous medical treatment cyclosporin A (CyA) (5 mg/kg) and azathioprine (3 mg/kg) 3 days prior to transplantation. Group III received the same medical treatment and simultaneously 12 grays of irradiation in 5 equal fractions with a high rate (100 cGy/min) or a low rate (1.6 cGy/min) prior to transplantation. Group IV also received 12 grays in 5 fractions at a high rate followed by the medical treatment started 5 days after TLI and continued until the day of transplantation. Antibody and serum cyclosporine levels were monitored. Histology specimen were analyzed at the end of the experiment. Mean GST (graft survival time) in group I and II was 140 +/- 35 min and 117 +/- 27.4 min respectively. The histological features of these hearts suggested acute humoral rejection (hemorrhage, thrombosis, and edema) without cellular infiltration. In group III, one heart functioned 4.5 days with pathological features of cellular rejection and a second animal died at 6 hours with a functioning graft with no evidence of an acute rejection. Both had been treated with the low rate TLI protocol (1.6 cGy/min). The mean GST in this group was 1080 +/- 794 min. In Group IV, one graft functioned for 6.5 days and another for 3.25 days. Mean GST was significantly increased in this group to 4800 +/- 2647 min (p < 0.05). A cellular infiltration was seen in this two grafts. The remaining graft was rejected in 6 hours with histological lesions typical of acute humoral rejection. Antibodies levels at the time of transplantation were lowest (40%) in group IV and in the low rate irradiation group. The ability of TLI to induce tolerance and to prolong survival in a discordant xenograft model depends upon cumulative dose, rate of irradiation, delay between TLI and graft placement, and combined treatment with immunosuppressive drugs. A high rate of TLI and graft placement is delayed. Low rates of irradiation may be beneficial when there is a very short period between treatment and transplantation. These findings highlight the potential usefulness of TLI in combination with immunosuppressive drug therapy when antibody-mediated rejection occurs, such as with xenograft and in sensitized patient.
使用不匹配的异种移植物可能会解决一些供体短缺问题。评估了全身淋巴照射(TLI)和传统药物治疗对这种不匹配移植排斥模型的有益效果。将24个羊心脏异位移植到24头猪的腹部。第一组不接受治疗(对照组)。第二组在移植前3天接受环孢素A(CyA)(5mg/kg)和硫唑嘌呤(3mg/kg)的持续静脉药物治疗。第三组接受相同的药物治疗,并在移植前同时以高剂量率(100cGy/min)或低剂量率(1.6cGy/min)分5等份给予12Gy的照射。第四组也以高剂量率分5次给予12Gy照射,随后在TLI后5天开始药物治疗并持续至移植当天。监测抗体和血清环孢素水平。在实验结束时分析组织学标本。第一组和第二组的平均移植物存活时间(GST)分别为140±35分钟和117±27.4分钟。这些心脏的组织学特征提示急性体液排斥(出血、血栓形成和水肿),无细胞浸润。在第三组中,一颗心脏功能维持了4.5天,具有细胞排斥的病理特征,第二只动物在6小时时死亡,其移植物功能正常,无急性排斥的证据。两者均接受低剂量率TLI方案(1.6cGy/min)治疗。该组的平均GST为1080±794分钟。在第四组中,一个移植物功能维持了6.5天,另一个维持了3.25天。该组的平均GST显著增加至4800±2647分钟(p<0.05)。在这两个移植物中可见细胞浸润。其余移植物在6小时内被排斥,具有急性体液排斥的典型组织学病变。移植时第四组和低剂量率照射组的抗体水平最低(40%)。TLI在不匹配异种移植模型中诱导耐受和延长存活的能力取决于累积剂量、照射率、TLI与移植物植入之间的间隔以及与免疫抑制药物的联合治疗。TLI的高剂量率和移植物植入延迟。当治疗与移植之间的间隔非常短时,低剂量率照射可能有益。这些发现突出了在发生抗体介导的排斥反应时,如异种移植和致敏患者中,TLI与免疫抑制药物联合治疗的潜在有用性。