Boustani Malaz, Watson Lea, Fultz Bridget, Perkins Anthony J, Druckenbrod Richard
Indiana University Center for Aging Research and Regenstrief Institute, Inc., Indiana 46202, USA.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2003 Sep;18(9):780-6. doi: 10.1002/gps.918.
In a recent systematic review of the evidence for dementia screening to support recommendations from the US Preventive Services Task Force, we found no evidence regarding the interest or willingness of older adults to be screened, and insufficient evidence to provide an estimate of the potential harms of dementia screening.
In an attempt to address the acceptability of dementia screening, we asked older adults living in two Continuous Care Retirement Communities (CCRC) if they would agree to routine screening for memory problems.
Cross-sectional study using self-administered mailed survey questionnaires.
Two CCRCs in Orange County, North Carolina.
500 residents of the independent living section of CCRCs.
There was a 64% survey response rate. Of these, 49% of participants stated they would agree to routine screening for memory problems. In comparison to people who would not agree to routine memory screening, those who accepted memory screening were more likely to accept depression screening, be male, use drug-administration assisted devices, and take more medications.
Approximately half of the residents in this affluent residential community setting were not willing to be screened routinely for memory problems. This high refusal rate indicates that dementia screening may be associated with perceived harms. We must improve our understanding of the decision-making process driving individual's beliefs and behaviors about dementia screening before implementing any broad-based screening initiatives for dementia or cognitive impairment.
在最近一项对痴呆症筛查证据的系统评价中,旨在支持美国预防服务工作组的建议,我们未发现关于老年人接受筛查的兴趣或意愿的证据,且没有足够证据来估计痴呆症筛查的潜在危害。
为探讨痴呆症筛查的可接受性,我们询问了居住在两个持续照料退休社区(CCRC)的老年人是否同意进行记忆问题的常规筛查。
采用自行邮寄调查问卷的横断面研究。
北卡罗来纳州奥兰治县的两个CCRC。
CCRC独立生活区的500名居民。
调查回复率为64%。其中,49%的参与者表示他们会同意进行记忆问题的常规筛查。与不同意进行常规记忆筛查的人相比,接受记忆筛查的人更有可能接受抑郁症筛查、为男性、使用药物辅助设备且服用更多药物。
在这个富裕的居住社区环境中,约一半居民不愿意接受记忆问题的常规筛查。如此高的拒绝率表明痴呆症筛查可能与感知到的危害有关。在实施任何广泛的痴呆症或认知障碍筛查计划之前,我们必须更好地理解驱动个人对痴呆症筛查的信念和行为的决策过程。