Bostwick Kimberly S, Prum Richard O
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA.
J Exp Biol. 2003 Oct;206(Pt 20):3693-706. doi: 10.1242/jeb.00598.
Basic kinematic and detailed physical mechanisms of avian, non-vocal sound production are both unknown. Here, for the first time, field-generated high-speed video recordings and acoustic analyses are used to test numerous competing hypotheses of the kinematics underlying sonations, or non-vocal communicative sounds, produced by two genera of Pipridae, Manacus and Pipra (Aves). Eleven behaviorally and acoustically distinct sonations are characterized, five of which fall into a specific acoustic class of relatively loud, brief, broad-frequency sound pulses, or snaps. The hypothesis that one kinematic mechanism of snap production is used within and between birds in general, and manakins specifically, is rejected. Instead, it is verified that three of four competing hypotheses of the kinematic mechanisms used for producing snaps, namely: (1). above-the-back wing-against-wing claps, (2). wing-against-body claps and (3). wing-into-air flicks, are employed between these two clades, and a fourth mechanism, (4). wing-against-tail feather interactions, is discovered. The kinematic mechanisms used to produce snaps are invariable within each identified sonation, despite the fact that a diversity of kinematic mechanisms are used among sonations. The other six sonations described are produced by kinematic mechanisms distinct from those used to create snaps, but are difficult to distinguish from each other and from the kinematics of flight. These results provide the first detailed kinematic information on mechanisms of sonation in birds in general, and the Pipridae specifically. Further, these results provide the first evidence that acoustically similar avian sonations, such as brief, broad frequency snaps, can be produced by diverse kinematic means, both among and within species. The use of high-speed video recordings in the field in a comparative manner documents the diversity of kinematic mechanisms used to sonate, and uncovers a hidden, sexually selected radiation of behavioral and communicative diversity in the Pipridae.
鸟类非发声声音产生的基本运动学和详细物理机制均不为人知。在此,首次利用野外生成的高速视频记录和声分析,来检验关于雀形目侏儒鸟科两个属(曼氏侏儒鸟属和侏儒鸟属,鸟纲)发出的鸣声(即非发声交流声音)背后运动学的众多相互竞争的假说。对11种行为和声学上不同的鸣声进行了特征描述,其中5种属于相对响亮、短暂、宽频声音脉冲或噼啪声的特定声学类别。关于噼啪声产生的一种运动学机制在鸟类内部和之间普遍使用,特别是在侏儒鸟中使用的假说被否定。相反,已证实用于产生噼啪声的运动学机制的四个相互竞争的假说中的三个,即:(1)背部上方翅膀对翅膀拍打,(2)翅膀对身体拍打,以及(3)翅膀向空中轻弹,在这两个进化枝之间被采用,并且发现了第四个机制,(4)翅膀与尾羽的相互作用。用于产生噼啪声的运动学机制在每个已识别的鸣声中是不变的,尽管在鸣声之间使用了多种运动学机制。所描述的其他六种鸣声是由与用于产生噼啪声的机制不同的运动学机制产生的,但彼此之间以及与飞行运动学难以区分。这些结果总体上提供了关于鸟类鸣声机制的首个详细运动学信息,特别是关于侏儒鸟科的。此外,这些结果提供了首个证据,表明声学上相似的鸟类鸣声,如短暂、宽频的噼啪声,可以通过物种间和物种内的多种运动学方式产生。以比较方式在野外使用高速视频记录记录了用于发声的运动学机制的多样性,并揭示了侏儒鸟科中行为和交流多样性的一种隐藏的、性选择的辐射。