Wainø M, Bang D D, Lund M, Nordentoft S, Andersen J S, Pedersen K, Madsen M
Department of Poultry, Fish and Fur Animals, Danish Veterinary Institute, Arhus N, Denmark.
J Appl Microbiol. 2003;95(4):649-55. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2672.2003.01996.x.
To validate a phenotypic Campylobacter species identification method employed to identify campylobacters in broilers by comparison with campylobacterial species identification using various species-specific PCR analyses.
From a collection of 2733 phenotypically identified campylobacterial cultures, 108 Campylobacter jejuni cultures and 351 campylobacterial cultures other than Camp. jejuni were subjected to various species-specific PCR assays. On the basis of the genotypic tests, it was demonstrated that Camp. jejuni and Camp. coli constituted approx. 99% of all cultures, while other species identified were Helicobacter pullorum, Camp. lari and Camp. upsaliensis. However, 29% of the 309 Camp. coli cultures identified by phenotypic tests were hippurate-variable or negative Camp. jejuni cultures, whereas some Camp. lari cultures and unspeciated campylobacter cultures belonged to H. pullorum. It was also notable that 2-6% of the cultures were, in fact, mixed cultures.
The phenotypic identification scheme employed failed to appropriately differentiate Campylobacter species and particularly to identify the closely related species, H. pullorum.
Future phenotypic test schemes should be designed to allow a more accurate differentiation of Campylobacter and related species. Preferably, the phenotypic tests should be supplemented with a genotypic strategy to disclose the true campylobacterial species diversity in broilers.
通过与使用各种种特异性PCR分析进行弯曲菌属物种鉴定相比较,验证一种用于鉴定肉鸡中弯曲菌的表型弯曲菌属物种鉴定方法。
从2733份经表型鉴定的弯曲菌培养物中选取108份空肠弯曲菌培养物和351份非空肠弯曲菌的弯曲菌培养物,进行各种种特异性PCR检测。基于基因型测试,结果表明空肠弯曲菌和结肠弯曲菌约占所有培养物的99%,而鉴定出的其他物种为拉氏螺杆菌、海鸥弯曲菌和乌普萨拉弯曲菌。然而,通过表型测试鉴定的309份结肠弯曲菌培养物中,有29%为空肠弯曲菌马尿酸盐可变或阴性培养物,而一些海鸥弯曲菌培养物和未分类的弯曲菌培养物属于拉氏螺杆菌。同样值得注意的是,2%至6%的培养物实际上是混合培养物。
所采用的表型鉴定方案未能适当地区分弯曲菌属物种,特别是未能鉴定出与之密切相关的物种拉氏螺杆菌。
未来的表型测试方案应设计得能够更准确地区分弯曲菌属及相关物种。最好在表型测试的基础上辅以基因型策略,以揭示肉鸡中真正的弯曲菌属物种多样性。