Brembilla-Perrot Béatrice, Miljoen Hielko, Houriez Pierre, Beurrier Daniel, Nippert Marc, Vançon Anne Claire, de la Chaise Arnaud Terrier, Louis Pierre, Mock Laurent, Sadoul Nicolas, Andronache Marius
Cardiology A, CHU of Brabois, F54500 Vandoeuvre Rue du Morvan, F54500 Vandoeuvre les Nancy, France.
Resuscitation. 2003 Sep;58(3):319-27. doi: 10.1016/s0300-9572(03)00154-0.
The purpose of this study was to determine the causes and the prognosis of consecutive patients resuscitated from cardiac arrest occurring in a general hospital. We assessed 28 females and 94 males (aged 13-82 years) who were resuscitated from cardiac arrest not attributable to acute myocardial infarction. Ventricular fibrillation (VF) was documented in 97. Non-cardiac causes were excluded. Non-invasive studies (24 h Holter monitoring, 2D echocardiogram, signal-averaged ECG, exercise testing, magnetic resonance imaging) and invasive studies (right and left ventricular angiography, coronary angiography and complete electrophysiologic study (EPS) were performed.
An underlying cardiac disease was found in 107 patients (88%). Patients were followed for a period ranging from 6 months to 10 years (mean 4+/-5 years). Several causes for cardiac arrest were identified and treated specifically. The prognosis was variable. Among surviving patients the following causes of cardiac arrest were found: Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome (n=2), rapid supraventricular tachycardia (n=6), acquired or congenital long QT syndrome (n=7), complete atrioventricular block (n=3), proarrhythmic effect of an antiarrhythmic drug (n=5), vasospastic angina (normal coronary arteries) (n=5). Among ten patients with VF related to cardiac ischaemia two died suddenly. Ventricular tachycardia (VT) or VF was the main cause leading to resuscitation after cardiac arrest (n=64). The risk of recurrence of arrest is confirmed in the present study particularly in patients in whom VT/VF could not be suppressed by antiarrhythmic drug therapy (n=45) and in those where an ICD was not implanted (18 cardiac deaths (nine sudden cardiac deaths (SCD's)). The cause of cardiac arrest was not elucidated in 20 patients (16%). The prognosis of these patients differed according to the documentation of VF at the time of cardiac arrest: of those with documented VF (n=12), six patients died suddenly (one with an ICD); of those without documented VF (n=8), all are alive.
To determine the precise cause of cardiac arrest was the first problem; the diagnosis of cardiac arrest clearly was erroneous in 8 of 122 patients (6.5%). In other patients, a ventricular tachyarrhythmia was identified as the cause for cardiac arrest in half of the population; the indication for an ICD is evident in this group. In 31% of patients with proven cardiac arrest, another arrhythmia requiring specific treatment was identified and ICD implantation was avoided; these patients had a survival of 92% at 3 years. In patients without an identified cause of cardiac arrest and negative EPS, the prognosis was unfavorable only in those with documented VF.
本研究旨在确定综合医院中连续发生心脏骤停后复苏患者的病因及预后情况。我们评估了28名女性和94名男性(年龄13 - 82岁),这些患者因非急性心肌梗死导致心脏骤停后复苏成功。记录到97例室颤(VF)。排除非心脏病因。进行了无创检查(24小时动态心电图监测、二维超声心动图、信号平均心电图、运动试验、磁共振成像)和有创检查(左右心室造影、冠状动脉造影及完整的电生理研究(EPS))。
107例患者(88%)发现有潜在心脏疾病。患者随访时间为6个月至10年(平均4±5年)。确定了心脏骤停的多种病因并进行了针对性治疗。预后各不相同。在存活患者中发现以下心脏骤停病因:预激综合征(n = 2)、快速室上性心动过速(n = 6)、获得性或先天性长QT综合征(n = 7)、完全性房室传导阻滞(n = 3)、抗心律失常药物的促心律失常作用(n = 5)、变异性心绞痛(冠状动脉正常)(n = 5)。在10例与心肌缺血相关的室颤患者中,2例突然死亡。室性心动过速(VT)或室颤是导致心脏骤停后复苏的主要原因(n = 64)。本研究证实了心脏骤停复发的风险,特别是在那些抗心律失常药物治疗无法抑制VT/VF的患者中(n = 45)以及未植入植入式心律转复除颤器(ICD)的患者中(18例心脏死亡(9例心源性猝死(SCD)))。20例患者(16%)心脏骤停的病因未明确。这些患者的预后根据心脏骤停时室颤的记录情况而有所不同:记录到室颤的患者(n = 12)中,6例突然死亡(1例植入了ICD);未记录到室颤的患者(n = 8)均存活。
确定心脏骤停的确切病因是首要问题;122例患者中有8例(6.5%)心脏骤停的诊断明显错误。在其他患者中,半数人群的心脏骤停病因被确定为室性快速心律失常;这组患者植入ICD的指征明显。在31%已证实心脏骤停的患者中,确定了另一种需要特殊治疗的心律失常,从而避免了植入ICD;这些患者3年生存率为92%。在未确定心脏骤停病因且电生理研究结果为阴性的患者中,仅记录到室颤的患者预后不佳。