Raine C, Saliba K, Chippindale A J, McLean N R
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Royal Victoria Infirmary, Queen Victoria Road, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK.
Br J Plast Surg. 2003 Oct;56(7):637-43. doi: 10.1016/s0007-1226(03)00358-8.
In a retrospective analysis of the preoperative imaging of patients presenting with primary malignant parotid disease, all relevant images were collected and reviewed by two experienced head and neck radiologists, blinded to the diagnosis. Forty-two patients (25 male, 17 female), median age 67.5 years (range 15-86), were included in the study of which 32 had undergone CT scanning, nine MR and three ultrasound. Forty tumours (93%) were correctly diagnosed as malignant when compared with histology. The two false negatives arose in a patient who had received an ultrasound scan only and in a patient with lymphoma, whose CT scan was reported as a pleomorphic adenoma. Neither had undergone prior radiotherapy. A poorly defined tumour boundary was the most consistent observation for both MR and CT images for the malignant tumours examined. Local infiltration was correctly correlated with pathological findings in eight of the nine MR scans, however, CT proved less reliable, correct in 14 of 24 cases (p=0.01). No correlation was identified between any of the imaging features examined and the final histological diagnosis. A poorly defined tumour boundary with evidence of local invasion was the best indicator of malignancy and was reported more frequently from MR scans than from CT. Imaging alone, however, proved unreliable in the prediction of final histological diagnosis or grade of tumour.
在一项对原发性腮腺恶性疾病患者术前影像的回顾性分析中,收集了所有相关影像,并由两位经验丰富的头颈放射科医生进行审阅,他们对诊断结果不知情。42例患者(25例男性,17例女性)纳入研究,中位年龄67.5岁(范围15 - 86岁),其中32例接受了CT扫描,9例接受了磁共振成像(MR)检查,3例接受了超声检查。与组织学结果相比,40个肿瘤(93%)被正确诊断为恶性。两例假阴性病例中,一例仅接受了超声检查,另一例为淋巴瘤患者,其CT扫描报告为多形性腺瘤。两例患者均未接受过放疗。对于所检查的恶性肿瘤,边界不清是磁共振成像和CT图像最一致的表现。9例磁共振扫描中有8例局部浸润与病理结果正确相关,然而,CT的可靠性较差,24例中有14例正确(p = 0.01)。在所检查的任何影像特征与最终组织学诊断之间均未发现相关性。边界不清且有局部浸润证据是恶性肿瘤的最佳指标,磁共振扫描报告的频率高于CT。然而,仅靠影像学检查在预测最终组织学诊断或肿瘤分级方面被证明是不可靠的。