Ali Niloufer Sultan, Azam Syed Iqbal, Noor Rahat
Department of Family Medicine, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi.
J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2003 Sep;13(9):501-3.
To understand the existing food beliefs regarding hot, cold and badi (gas-producing) properties of different food items and also to assess whether there is any relationship with education of women and these beliefs.
A cross-sectional study.
Community Health Center (CHC), The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi from July to September 2000.
Four hundred adult female respondents, who came to CHC as a patient or as an attendant, were interviewed after taking verbal consent. A self-administered pre-coded and pre-tested questionnaire was filled by the respondent. Descriptive frequencies and cross tabulation were computed to assess the existing food beliefs. Chi-square test was used to assess the association between education level of women and belief regarding these food items.
More than three-fourth of respondents were literate. The percentages of respondents saying that certain foods were hot, cold and badi were 71%, 55% and 80% respectively. Meat, either beef or mutton, fish, egg, chicken, was perceived as hot by majority of the respondents. Majority of vegetables was perceived as cold foods in our study. The other foods like rice, yogurt, banana, watermelon, milk and cold drink were also thought to be cold by many of the respondents. Cabbage, cauliflower, potato, rice, gram and mash pulses (chane and mash-ki-dal) were highly rated as badi foods. Level of education of women didn t show any statistically significant difference in keeping beliefs regarding hot, cold and badi properties of food items.
A significant concept of different properties of food exists in our culture. We recommend future studies to explore scientific basis for classifying hot, cold or badi foods and also to look into its impact on health by their restriction based on their beliefs.
了解关于不同食物的热、冷及产气(“巴迪”)属性的现有饮食观念,并评估女性的教育程度与这些观念之间是否存在关联。
一项横断面研究。
2000年7月至9月,卡拉奇阿迦汗大学医院社区健康中心。
对400名成年女性受访者进行了访谈,她们是以患者或陪同人员的身份来到社区健康中心的,访谈前获得了她们的口头同意。由受访者自行填写一份预先编码和预测试的问卷。计算描述性频率和交叉列表以评估现有的饮食观念。使用卡方检验来评估女性教育程度与对这些食物的观念之间的关联。
超过四分之三的受访者识字。表示某些食物是热性、凉性和产气的受访者比例分别为71%、55%和80%。大多数受访者认为牛肉或羊肉、鱼、蛋、鸡肉等肉类是热性食物。在我们的研究中,大多数蔬菜被认为是凉性食物。许多受访者还认为米饭、酸奶、香蕉、西瓜、牛奶和冷饮等其他食物也是凉性的。卷心菜、花椰菜、土豆、米饭、鹰嘴豆和豆类(鹰嘴豆和碎粒木豆)被高度评为产气食物。女性的教育程度在对食物的热、冷及产气属性的观念方面没有显示出任何统计学上的显著差异。
在我们的文化中存在关于食物不同属性的重要观念。我们建议未来的研究探索对热性、凉性或产气食物进行分类的科学依据,并研究基于这些观念对其进行限制对健康的影响。