Carabin Hélène, Escalona Marisela, Marshall Clare, Vivas-Martínez Sarai, Botto Carlos, Joseph Lawrence, Basáñez María-Gloria
Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Oklahoma University Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, USA.
Bull World Health Organ. 2003;81(7):482-90. Epub 2003 Sep 3.
To develop a Bayesian hierarchical model for human onchocerciasis with which to explore the factors that influence prevalence of microfilariae in the Amazonian focus of onchocerciasis and predict the probability of any community being at least mesoendemic (>20% prevalence of microfilariae), and thus in need of priority ivermectin treatment.
Models were developed with data from 732 individuals aged > or =15 years who lived in 29 Yanomami communities along four rivers of the south Venezuelan Orinoco basin. The models' abilities to predict prevalences of microfilariae in communities were compared. The deviance information criterion, Bayesian P-values, and residual values were used to select the best model with an approximate cross-validation procedure.
A three-level model that acknowledged clustering of infection within communities performed best, with host age and sex included at the individual level, a river-dependent altitude effect at the community level, and additional clustering of communities along rivers. This model correctly classified 25/29 (86%) villages with respect to their need for priority ivermectin treatment.
Bayesian methods are a flexible and useful approach for public health research and control planning. Our model acknowledges the clustering of infection within communities, allows investigation of links between individual- or community-specific characteristics and infection, incorporates additional uncertainty due to missing covariate data, and informs policy decisions by predicting the probability that a new community is at least mesoendemic.
建立一种用于人类盘尾丝虫病的贝叶斯分层模型,以探讨影响亚马逊盘尾丝虫病流行区微丝蚴血症患病率的因素,并预测任何社区至少为中度流行(微丝蚴血症患病率>20%)从而需要优先进行伊维菌素治疗的概率。
利用居住在委内瑞拉南部奥里诺科河流域四条河流沿岸29个亚诺马米社区中732名年龄≥15岁个体的数据建立模型。比较这些模型预测社区微丝蚴血症患病率的能力。采用偏差信息准则、贝叶斯P值和残差值,通过近似交叉验证程序选择最佳模型。
一个承认社区内感染聚集性的三级模型表现最佳,在个体层面纳入宿主年龄和性别,在社区层面纳入与河流相关的海拔效应,以及沿河流的社区额外聚集性。该模型在优先进行伊维菌素治疗需求方面正确分类了25/29(86%)个村庄。
贝叶斯方法是公共卫生研究和控制规划中一种灵活且有用的方法。我们的模型承认社区内感染的聚集性,允许研究个体或社区特定特征与感染之间 的联系,纳入因协变量数据缺失而产生的额外不确定性,并通过预测新社区至少为中度流行的概率为政策决策提供依据。