Li Jing Yan, Wu Chuan Fen
Laboratory of Cellular and Molecular Evolution, Kunming Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Kunming, Yunnan 650223, China.
Cell Res. 2003 Aug;13(4):219-27. doi: 10.1038/sj.cr.7290167.
The origin of cytoskeleton and the origin of relevant intracellular transportation system are big problems for understanding the emergence of eukaryotic cells. The present article summarized relevant information of evidences and molecular traces on the origin of actin, tubulin, the chaperonin system for folding them, myosins, kinesins, axonemal dyneins and cytoplasmic dyneins. On this basis the authors proposed a series of works, which should be done in the future, and indicated the ways for reaching the targets. These targets are mainly: 1) the reconstruction of evolutionary path from MreB protein of archaeal ancestor of eukaryotic cells to typical actin; 2) the finding of the MreB or MreB-related proteins in crenarchaea and using them to examine J. A. Lake's hypothesis on the origin of eukaryote from "eocytes" (crenarchaea); 3) the examinations of the existence and distribution of cytoskeleton made of MreB-related protein within coccoid archaea, especially in amoeboid archaeon Thermoplasm acidophilum; 4) using Thermoplasma as a model of archaeal ancestor of eukaryotic cells; 5) the searching for the homolog of ancestral dynein in present-day living archaea. During the writing of this article, Margulis' famous spirochaete hypothesis on the origin of flagella and cilia was unexpectedly involved and analyzed from aspects of tubulins, dyneins and spirochaetes. Actually, spirochaete cannot be reasonably assumed as the ectosymbiotic ancestor of eukaryotic flagella and cilia, since their swing depends upon large amount of bacterial flagella beneath the flexible outer wall, but not depends upon their intracellular tubules and the assumed dyneins. In this case, if they had "evolved" into cilia and lost their bacterial flagella, they would immediately become immobile! In fact, tubulin and dynein-like proteins have not been found in any spirochaete.
细胞骨架的起源以及相关细胞内运输系统的起源是理解真核细胞出现的重大问题。本文总结了关于肌动蛋白、微管蛋白、折叠它们的伴侣蛋白系统、肌球蛋白、驱动蛋白、轴丝动力蛋白和胞质动力蛋白起源的证据及分子痕迹的相关信息。在此基础上,作者提出了一系列未来应开展的工作,并指明了实现目标的途径。这些目标主要包括:1)重建从真核细胞古菌祖先的MreB蛋白到典型肌动蛋白的进化路径;2)在泉古菌中寻找MreB或与MreB相关的蛋白,并利用它们检验J.A.莱克关于真核生物起源于“曙细胞”(泉古菌)的假说;3)检测由MreB相关蛋白构成的细胞骨架在球状古菌内的存在及分布情况,特别是在变形古菌嗜热栖热菌中的情况;4)将嗜热栖热菌用作真核细胞古菌祖先的模型;5)在现存的活古菌中寻找祖先动力蛋白的同源物。在撰写本文过程中,意外涉及并从微管蛋白、动力蛋白和螺旋体方面分析了马古利斯著名的关于鞭毛和纤毛起源的螺旋体假说。实际上,不能合理假定螺旋体是真核生物鞭毛和纤毛的胞外共生祖先,因为它们的摆动依赖于柔性外壁下方大量的细菌鞭毛,而非依赖于其细胞内小管及假定的动力蛋白。在这种情况下,如果它们“进化”成纤毛并失去细菌鞭毛,它们将立即失去运动能力!事实上,在任何螺旋体中都未发现微管蛋白和类动力蛋白。