McElroy Betty Howell, Miller Shelley Porter
The Heritage Center, Provo, Utah 84604, USA.
Am J Ther. 2003 Sep-Oct;10(5):324-9. doi: 10.1097/00045391-200309000-00004.
Each year, more than 62 million cases of the common cold in the United States require medical attention and more than 80% affect school-aged children. The objective of this prospective, intent-to-treat, phase IV study was to determine the therapeutic and prophylactic effectiveness of zinc gluconate glycine lozenges (Cold-Eeze) for the common cold. Zinc lozenges were administered once daily during the cold season for prophylaxis. For therapeutic purposes, lozenges were given 4 times per day. The primary objective of the study was the treatment effect on cold duration, and the secondary objective was the effect on the number of common colds. A putative control from our previous study was used for comparison. A total of 178 children, ages 12 to 18 years, was enrolled, of which 134 met criteria for efficacy analysis. The average cold duration with therapeutic lozenge use was 6.9 +/- 3.1 days, significantly shorter than the 9.0 +/- 3.5 days found in the control group (P < 0.001). The mean number of colds was 1.28 +/- 1.03 with zinc lozenge prophylaxis versus 1.7 +/- 1.91 without prophylaxis (P < 0.05), a 25% reduction. With prophylaxis, 25% of the subjects did not experience a cold and two-thirds never had a cold or only had 1 cold. There was no antibiotic use for any cold, and there were no adverse events reported. Results of this study are consistent with those from our previous retrospective study showing significantly shorter cold duration and fewer colds with the use of zinc gluconate glycine lozenges. The zinc gluconate glycine lozenges are well tolerated and are an easy-to-administer therapy that has the potential to substantially reduce cold-related school absences and antibiotic use and misuse as well as to provide a cost saving.
在美国,每年有超过6200万例普通感冒病例需要医疗护理,其中超过80%影响学龄儿童。这项前瞻性、意向性治疗的IV期研究的目的是确定葡萄糖酸锌甘氨酸含片(Cold-Eeze)对普通感冒的治疗和预防效果。在感冒季节,锌含片每天服用一次用于预防。出于治疗目的,含片每天服用4次。该研究的主要目的是对感冒持续时间的治疗效果,次要目的是对普通感冒次数的影响。使用了我们之前研究中的一个假定对照进行比较。总共招募了178名12至18岁的儿童,其中134名符合疗效分析标准。使用治疗性含片时,平均感冒持续时间为6.9±3.1天,明显短于对照组的9.0±3.5天(P<0.001)。使用锌含片预防时,平均感冒次数为1.28±1.03次,而未预防时为1.7±1.91次(P<0.05),减少了25%。进行预防时,25%的受试者没有患感冒,三分之二的人从未患过感冒或只患过1次感冒。任何感冒均未使用抗生素,也未报告不良事件。本研究结果与我们之前的回顾性研究结果一致,表明使用葡萄糖酸锌甘氨酸含片可显著缩短感冒持续时间并减少感冒次数。葡萄糖酸锌甘氨酸含片耐受性良好,是一种易于给药的疗法,有可能大幅减少与感冒相关的缺课情况以及抗生素的使用和滥用,同时还能节省成本。