Bagley J G, Low K G
Department of Psychology, Bates College, Lewiston, MA 04240.
Clin Prev Dent. 1992 Nov-Dec;14(6):25-30.
This study examined the relationship between dental compliance and health locus of control in 41 college freshmen. Subjects were randomly assigned to either a control (N = 13) or experimental (N = 28) group. Dental flossing compliance was assessed in all subjects using a brief dental exam that assessed pocket depth and plaque as indexes of flossing behavior. The Multidimensional Health Locus of Control Scale was used to measure health locus of control. An educational, low-fear intervention, consisting of the presentation of a pictorial diagram of the progression of periodontal disease and discussion of the importance of flossing was presented to the experimental subjects before monitoring began. Control subjects underwent a brief dental examination and flossing instruction only. Self-reported flossing compliance was monitored for 24 days following the dental examination and intervention. Significant decreases in the dental exam variables associated with plaque were found for both the experimental and control conditions. The low-fear, educational intervention had no significant impact on compliance. Instead, a dental exam and self-monitoring were as effective at increasing flossing compliance as the more time-consuming educational approach. A significant increase in internality of health locus of control across all subjects was also found. No significant interaction was found between health locus of control and group, but a trend was apparent. Control subjects who were externally oriented had the lowest flossing compliance scores while internal subjects in both conditions had higher flossing compliance scores.
本研究调查了41名大学新生的牙齿护理依从性与健康控制点之间的关系。受试者被随机分为对照组(N = 13)或实验组(N = 28)。使用一项简短的牙科检查对所有受试者的牙线使用依从性进行评估,该检查以牙周袋深度和牙菌斑作为牙线使用行为的指标。采用多维健康控制点量表来测量健康控制点。在监测开始前,向实验组受试者进行了一项教育性的、低恐惧干预,内容包括展示牙周疾病进展的示意图以及讨论使用牙线的重要性。对照组受试者仅接受了一次简短的牙科检查和牙线使用指导。在牙科检查和干预后的24天内,对自我报告的牙线使用依从性进行了监测。在实验组和对照组中,与牙菌斑相关的牙科检查变量均显著下降。低恐惧的教育干预对依从性没有显著影响。相反,牙科检查和自我监测在提高牙线使用依从性方面与耗时更长的教育方法同样有效。在所有受试者中,健康控制点的内控性也显著增加。在健康控制点与组别之间未发现显著的交互作用,但有明显的趋势。外部导向的对照组受试者牙线使用依从性得分最低,而在两种情况下,内控性受试者的牙线使用依从性得分更高。