Aiken G E, Bransby D I
Department of Agronomy and Soils, Auburn University, AL 36849.
J Anim Sci. 1992 Oct;70(10):3234-7. doi: 10.2527/1992.70103234x.
Grazing experiments may use steers or cow-calf pairs for measuring animal performance on pasture treatments, but the validity of extrapolation between these classes of cattle has not been verified. A grazing study was conducted in the spring and summer of both 1988 and 1989 to determine stocking equivalents and stocking rate-weight gain relationships for steers and cow-calf pairs grazing Coastal bermuda grass (Cynodon dactylon [L.] pers.) oversown with rye (Secale cereale L.) and ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.). Average daily gain and stocking rate (SR; 3.2, 4.2, 6.2, and 7.4 animals per hectare for steers and 1.7, 2.5, 3.7, and 4.9 pairs per hectare for cow-calf pairs) were both adjusted so that comparisons could be made on an equal BW basis. Disk meter height readings were used as measurements of forage accessibility. Disk meter height responses to SR did not differ (P greater than .10) between steer and cow-calf paddocks. There was a linear (P less than .001) decrease in ADG as SR increased, but this decline was steeper (P less than .001) for steers than for cows or suckling calves. Steers tended to be more productive than calves at low SR but less productive at high SR. Disk meter heights for the range of SR used in the study did not differ (P greater than .10) for steers and cow-calf pairs at equivalent BW per hectare. Our study suggests that live BW is a reasonable basis for determining forage requirements of steers and cow-calf pairs under grazing conditions, but extrapolation of production between classes of livestock will not be reliable.
放牧试验可使用阉牛或母牛-犊牛组合来衡量牧场处理方式下的动物生产性能,但这两类牛之间推断的有效性尚未得到验证。在1988年和1989年的春季及夏季进行了一项放牧研究,以确定放牧黑麦(黑麦草)和多花黑麦草混播的海岸百慕大草(狗牙根)时阉牛和母牛-犊牛组合的载畜当量及载畜率与体重增加的关系。平均日增重和载畜率(SR;阉牛每公顷3.2、4.2、6.2和7.4头,母牛-犊牛组合每公顷1.7、2.5、3.7和4.9对)均进行了调整,以便能在相等体重基础上进行比较。圆盘测草仪高度读数用作牧草可及性的测量指标。阉牛和母牛-犊牛围场中圆盘测草仪高度对载畜率的反应无差异(P大于0.10)。随着载畜率增加,平均日增重呈线性下降(P小于0.001),但阉牛的下降幅度比母牛或哺乳犊牛更陡(P小于0.001)。在低载畜率时,阉牛的生产性能往往比犊牛高,但在高载畜率时则较低。在研究使用的载畜率范围内,每公顷体重相等的阉牛和母牛-犊牛组合的圆盘测草仪高度无差异(P大于0.10)。我们的研究表明,活体重是确定放牧条件下阉牛和母牛-犊牛组合牧草需求的合理依据,但不同类牲畜之间产量的推断不可靠。