Rival Christina, Olivier Isabelle, Ceyte Hadrien, Ferrel Carole
Laboratoire Sport et Performance Motrice, Université Joseph Fourier, B.P. 53, F-38041 Grenoble 9, France.
Exp Brain Res. 2003 Dec;153(3):378-81. doi: 10.1007/s00221-003-1559-5. Epub 2003 Sep 26.
It has been suggested that movements to visible or remembered targets are differently sensitive to the Müller-Lyer (ML) illusion. Indeed, when the target is continuously visible, movements rely on the veridical object characteristics, whereas remembered movements are thought to reflect the perceived characteristics of the object. The aim of the present study was to determine how movements to visible or remembered targets are influenced by the ML illusion in children aged 7 to 11 years old. Participants were asked to make a perceptual judgment or to point a shaft extremity of the ML configurations (Closed, Control, and Open) in three visual conditions (Closed Loop, Open Loop-0-s delay, and 5-s delay). Perceptual (Perceived Length, PL) and motor (Movement Magnitude, MM, and Peak velocity, PV) variables were measured. Results showed that PL was influenced to the same extent by the ML illusion in the three visual conditions. Moreover, it appears that in subjects as young as 7 years old, the activation of the ventral system features may give rise to the perceptual illusion effect observed in all three experimental conditions. However, regardless of the subject's age, MM and PV were only sensitive in the delay condition, suggesting that delayed movements are also mediated by the ventral stream. These data suggested that the distinction between perception and motor visual pathways appears quite early during childhood (before 7 years). Our data also demonstrated that children were relying on both visual processing streams during perceptual as well as visuomotor tasks during remembered movements.
有人认为,朝向可见或记忆目标的动作对缪勒-莱尔(ML)错觉的敏感度不同。的确,当目标持续可见时,动作依赖于真实的物体特征,而记忆中的动作则被认为反映了物体的感知特征。本研究的目的是确定7至11岁儿童中,朝向可见或记忆目标的动作如何受到ML错觉的影响。参与者被要求在三种视觉条件下(闭环、开环-0秒延迟和5秒延迟)进行感知判断或指向ML构型(闭合、对照和开放)的轴端。测量了感知(感知长度,PL)和运动(运动幅度,MM,以及峰值速度,PV)变量。结果表明,在三种视觉条件下,PL受ML错觉的影响程度相同。此外,似乎在年仅7岁的受试者中,腹侧系统特征的激活可能会导致在所有三种实验条件下观察到的感知错觉效应。然而,无论受试者年龄如何,MM和PV仅在延迟条件下敏感,这表明延迟动作也由腹侧流介导。这些数据表明,感知和运动视觉通路之间的区分在儿童期相当早(7岁之前)就出现了。我们的数据还表明,儿童在感知任务以及记忆动作期间的视觉运动任务中都依赖于两种视觉处理流。