Bäumer Tobias, Lange Rüdiger, Liepert Joachim, Weiller Cornelius, Siebner Hartwig R, Rothwell John C, Münchau Alexander
Department of Neurology, University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany.
Neuroimage. 2003 Sep;20(1):550-60. doi: 10.1016/s1053-8119(03)00310-0.
We explored the aftereffects of two premotor 1 Hz rTMS sessions on motor cortex excitability in healthy humans. In experiment 1, 11 healthy right-handed volunteers received 20-min submotor threshold 1 Hz rTMS trains over the left premotor cortex on 2 consecutive days. Left motor cortex excitability was determined at baseline, immediately after, 30, 60, 120 min, and 24 h after each rTMS session. We measured motor thresholds, amplitudes of motor-evoked potentials, silent periods, and paired-pulse excitability at interstimulus intervals (ISI) of 3-7, 10, and 15 ms. In experiment 2, 5 volunteers received two identical rTMS trains on Days 1 and 7. Measurements were carried out on Day 1 (first rTMS train), Day 2, and Day 7 (second rTMS train). In experiment 1 there was a selective increase of paired pulse facilitation at an ISI of 7 ms after rTMS lasting for less than 30 min on Day 1. This effect was also present after rTMS on Day 2. However, it persisted for at least 2 h. In experiment 2 the same extra facilitation was induced by rTMS on Days 1 and 7 but not on Day 2. It lasted for less than 30 min on both Day 1 and Day 7. We conclude that 1 Hz premotor rTMS leads to cumulative plastic changes of intrinsic motor cortex excitability when repeated within 24 h but not after 1 week, implying the formation of memory after the first rTMS train lasting more than a day but less than a week.
我们探究了两次运动前区1赫兹重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)对健康人类运动皮层兴奋性的后续影响。在实验1中,11名健康的右利手志愿者连续两天接受了20分钟的阈下运动1赫兹rTMS刺激,刺激部位为左侧运动前区皮层。在每次rTMS刺激前的基线水平、刺激结束后即刻、30分钟、60分钟、120分钟以及24小时后,测定左侧运动皮层的兴奋性。我们测量了运动阈值、运动诱发电位的幅度、静息期以及在3 - 7毫秒、10毫秒和15毫秒的刺激间隔(ISI)下的配对脉冲兴奋性。在实验2中,5名志愿者在第1天和第7天接受了两次相同的rTMS刺激。在第1天(第一次rTMS刺激)、第2天和第7天(第二次rTMS刺激)进行测量。在实验1中,第1天rTMS刺激后,在7毫秒的ISI时配对脉冲易化有选择性增加,持续时间不到30分钟。第2天rTMS刺激后也出现了这种效应。然而,这种效应至少持续了2小时。在实验2中,第1天和第7天的rTMS刺激诱导了相同的额外易化,但第2天没有。在第1天和第7天,这种易化持续时间均不到30分钟。我们得出结论,当在24小时内重复进行时,1赫兹运动前区rTMS会导致运动皮层内在兴奋性的累积性可塑性变化,但在1周后则不会产生这种变化,这意味着第一次rTMS刺激后形成了持续超过一天但不到一周的记忆。