Chassoux Francine, Semah Franck, Bouilleret Viviane, Landre Elisabeth, Devaux Bertrand, Turak Baris, Nataf François, Roux François-Xavier
Department of Neurosurgery, Centre Hospitalier Sainte-Anne, 1 rue Cabanis, 75014 Paris, France.
Brain. 2004 Jan;127(Pt 1):164-74. doi: 10.1093/brain/awh014. Epub 2003 Oct 8.
Interictal hypometabolism is commonly found in mesio-temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE), but its pathophysiology remains incompletely understood. We hypothesized that metabolic changes reflect the preferential networks involved by ictal discharges. We analysed the topography of interictal hypometabolism according to electro-clinical patterns in 50 patients with unilateral hippocampal sclerosis (HS) and consistent features of MTLE. Based on electro-clinical correlations, we identified four groups: (i) mesial group (13 cases) characterized by mesial seizure onset without evidence of early spread beyond the temporal lobe; (ii) anterior mesio-lateral group (AML; 18 cases) with early anterior spread involving the anterior lateral temporal cortex and insulo-fronto-opercular areas; (iii) widespread mesio-lateral group (WML; 15 cases) with wide spread (involving both anterior and posterior lateral temporal and perisylvian areas); and (iv) bitemporal (BT) group (four cases) with early contralateral temporal spread. Results of [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose-PET imaging in each group were compared with those of 10 control subjects using statistical parametric mapping software (SPM99). MRI data and surgical outcome in each group were compared with metabolic findings. Hypometabolism was limited to hippocampal gyrus, temporal pole and insula in the mesial group. Gradual involvement of lateral temporal cortex, insula and perisylvian areas was observed in the AML and WML groups. The BT group differed from the others with mild bitemporal involvement, bilateral insular hypometabolism and longer epilepsy duration. MRI structural abnormalities outside of the mesial formations were detected in 65% of the cases. Neither the severity of HS nor temporal atrophy appeared related to the topography of hypometabolism. However, temporal hypometabolism was more extended when temporo-polar signal changes were detected. Among operated patients (n = 43), seizure-free outcome was obtained in 82%. Surgical outcome appeared more favourable in the mesial group. However, the difference between the four groups was not significant. Our results suggest that hypometabolism in MTLE may be related to ictal discharge generation and spread pathways, even if structural changes and epilepsy duration may also play a role.
发作间期代谢减低常见于内侧颞叶癫痫(MTLE),但其病理生理学仍未完全明确。我们推测代谢变化反映了发作期放电所涉及的优势网络。我们根据50例单侧海马硬化(HS)且具有MTLE一致特征患者的电临床模式,分析了发作间期代谢减低的地形图。基于电临床相关性,我们确定了四组:(i)内侧组(13例),其特征为内侧发作起始,无证据表明早期扩散至颞叶以外;(ii)前内侧外侧组(AML;18例),早期向前扩散累及前外侧颞叶皮质和岛叶 - 额 - 眶额区;(iii)广泛内侧外侧组(WML;15例),广泛扩散(累及前、后外侧颞叶和外侧裂周围区域);以及(iv)双侧颞叶(BT)组(4例),早期对侧颞叶扩散。使用统计参数映射软件(SPM99)将每组的[18F]氟脱氧葡萄糖 - PET成像结果与10名对照受试者的结果进行比较。将每组的MRI数据和手术结果与代谢结果进行比较。内侧组的代谢减低局限于海马回、颞极和岛叶。在AML组和WML组中观察到外侧颞叶皮质、岛叶和外侧裂周围区域逐渐受累。BT组与其他组不同,表现为双侧颞叶轻度受累、双侧岛叶代谢减低和癫痫病程较长。65%的病例在海马结构以外检测到MRI结构异常。HS的严重程度和颞叶萎缩均与代谢减低的地形图无关。然而,当检测到颞极信号变化时,颞叶代谢减低范围更广。在接受手术的患者(n = 43)中,82%获得了无发作结果。内侧组的手术结果似乎更有利。然而,四组之间的差异不显著。我们的结果表明,MTLE中的代谢减低可能与发作期放电的产生和传播途径有关,即使结构变化和癫痫病程也可能起作用。