Bell Joanna H, Bromnick Rachel D
School of Nursing, Social Work and Applied Health Studies, University of Hull, Cottingham Road, Hull, United Kingdom HU6 7RX.
Adolescence. 2003 Summer;38(150):205-19.
Traditional approaches to understanding the imaginary audience are challenged in this study. Three hundred sixty-one British schoolchildren (aged 14 and 15 years) were asked to express their worries and concerns, using grounded theory methodology. Qualitative responses were collated and coded according to emerging categories, with "what other people think" identified as the central concern. In particular, the findings are used to critique Elkind's (1967) theory of adolescent egocentrism. Data presented in this study suggest that adolescents worry about what other people think because there are real personal and social consequences. Such concerns are seen as being based in social reality and are not imaginary as Elkind suggested. In conclusion, new methodologies which place young people at the center of the analysis are advocated.
本研究对理解假想观众的传统方法提出了挑战。采用扎根理论方法,对361名英国学童(年龄在14至15岁之间)进行了调查,要求他们表达自己的担忧。对定性回答进行整理,并根据出现的类别进行编码,其中“其他人的想法”被确定为核心关注点。特别是,研究结果被用于批判埃尔金德(1967年)的青少年自我中心主义理论。本研究呈现的数据表明,青少年担心其他人的想法是因为存在实际的个人和社会后果。这种担忧被视为基于社会现实,而不像埃尔金德所认为的那样是假想的。总之,提倡采用将年轻人置于分析中心的新方法。