Erwin Deborah O, Ivory Jennifer, Stayton Charlie, Willis Mattye, Jandorf Lina, Thompson Hayley, Womack Sharita, Hurd Thelma C
Department of Surgery, Arkansas Cancer Research Center, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Arkansas Cancer Research Center, Little Rock, 72205, USA.
Cancer Control. 2003 Sep-Oct;10(5 Suppl):13-21. doi: 10.1177/107327480301005s03.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of replicating an evidence-based model, the Witness Project, for increasing breast and cervical cancer screening with African American women in a variety of locations and organizations in the United States. The quantitative and qualitative methods included a cadre of process and outcome measures to evaluate the effectiveness of the four-phase replication process. The intervention was replicated in 25 sites with 401 volunteers, delivering cancer education and screening programs to over 10,000 women. Key components and criteria of successful replication were established, and preliminary screening outcomes demonstrated a 43.4% increase in mammography in women aged 40 and older. This study demonstrates that the Witness Project model can be effectively replicated, that the replication process can be standardized, and that the replication sites were able to obtain positive screening results comparable to the original intervention outcomes. The model was not able to be effectively replicated with just the "turnkey" toolbox approach, but required additional technical assistance.
本研究的目的是调查复制一个基于证据的模式——见证项目,在美国不同地点和组织中提高非裔美国女性乳腺癌和宫颈癌筛查率的有效性。定量和定性方法包括一系列过程和结果指标,以评估四阶段复制过程的有效性。该干预措施在25个地点由401名志愿者进行了复制,为超过10000名女性提供了癌症教育和筛查项目。确定了成功复制的关键组成部分和标准,初步筛查结果显示40岁及以上女性的乳房X光检查率提高了43.4%。这项研究表明,见证项目模式可以有效地复制,复制过程可以标准化,并且复制地点能够获得与原始干预结果相当的阳性筛查结果。仅采用“交钥匙”工具箱方法无法有效复制该模式,而是需要额外的技术援助。