Sheahan Patrick, O'Keane Conor, Sheahan Jerome N, O'Dwyer Tadhg P
Department of Otolaryngology, Mater Misericordiae Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2003 Nov;129(5):571-6. doi: 10.1016/S0194-59980301582-1.
Despite the substantial rate of neck conversion reported among patients with early oral cancer, a policy of routine elective neck dissection has been criticized on the grounds that it confers little survival advantage while subjecting many to potentially avoidable morbidity. However, the identification of factors predictive of survival may allow for the identification of those patients who are more likely to benefit from elective neck treatment.
The clinical and histologic material of 71 patients with stage I or II squamous carcinoma of the oral cavity were reviewed. Patients were followed up for a minimum of 3 years after their surgery, and the impact of these variables on 3-year survival was assessed.
Increased tumor thickness was significantly predictive of decreased survival (P = 0.030). Although having no prognostic value alone, when combined with thickness, both pattern of invasion and gender increased the significance of the latter in predicting outcome. Conclusion and significance Measuring tumor thickness and pattern of invasion in patients with early oral cancer may allow for the identification of those patients with more aggressive disease who are more likely to benefit from elective neck treatment.
尽管早期口腔癌患者中报告的颈部转换率很高,但常规选择性颈部清扫术的政策受到了批评,理由是它几乎没有生存优势,同时使许多人遭受潜在的可避免的发病率。然而,识别预测生存的因素可能有助于识别那些更有可能从选择性颈部治疗中受益的患者。
回顾了71例I期或II期口腔鳞状癌患者的临床和组织学资料。患者术后至少随访3年,并评估这些变量对3年生存率的影响。
肿瘤厚度增加显著预示生存率降低(P = 0.030)。虽然单独没有预后价值,但与厚度相结合时,浸润模式和性别都增加了后者在预测结果方面的显著性。结论与意义 测量早期口腔癌患者的肿瘤厚度和浸润模式可能有助于识别那些患有更侵袭性疾病且更有可能从选择性颈部治疗中受益的患者。