Scultetus Anke H, Villavicencio J Leonel, Kao Tzu-Cheg, Gillespie David L, Ketron Gary D, Iafrati Mark D, Pikoulis Emmanouil, Eifert Sandra
Department of Surgery, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 2003 Nov;38(5):896-903. doi: 10.1016/s0741-5214(03)00920-0.
Postsclerotherapy pigmentation occurs in nearly 30% of patients. Hemosiderin, from degradation of the venous thrombus, is the possible cause. The hypothesis that early removal of the thrombus may eliminate or decrease the incidence of pigmentation has not been proved or documented. The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of early microthrombectomy on incidence of postsclerotherapy pigmentation.
This multicenter, randomized, controlled study involved 101 patients with varicose veins (100 women, 1 man; mean age, 46 years [range, 25-68 years]). Patients were divided into two groups, with veins 1 mm or less in diameter (group 1, n = 50) or veins 3 mm or less in diameter (group 2, n = 51). Group 1 was treated with Sotradecol (STD) 0.25%, and group 2 with STD 0.50%. In each patient, an area of varicosities was selected and divided into halves. One half was randomized to microthrombectomy and the other half served as control. Microthrombectomy was performed 1 to 3 weeks after treatment in the randomized half. Standard photographs were obtained before and 16 weeks after treatment, and were evaluated by three independent reviewers who were blinded to treatment assignments. Each reviewer received an identical set of pretreatment and posttreatment 10 x 15-cm color photographs of the study area, and completed a scoring sheet. Average of the scores was used to evaluate primary (pigmentation) and secondary (overall clinical improvement) end points. The paired t test and chi-square test were used for statistical analysis.
In group 1, microthrombectomized areas had statistically significant less pigmentation (P =.0047) and better overall clinical improvement scores (P =.0002) compared with the control side. In group 2 there was no significant difference between the two areas, but patients reported significant relief of pain and inflammation associated with postsclerotherapy thrombophlebitis.
In veins 1 mm or smaller, microthrombectomy reduced pigmentation and improved overall clinical results. In veins 3 mm or smaller, statistical significance was not achieved, but thrombectomy resulted in faster resolution of the postsclerotherapy pain and inflammation. On the basis of these results, microthrombectomy after sclerotherapy is recommended.
硬化治疗后色素沉着发生在近30%的患者中。静脉血栓降解产生的含铁血黄素可能是其原因。早期清除血栓可消除或降低色素沉着发生率这一假说尚未得到证实或记录。本研究的目的是探讨早期微血栓切除术对硬化治疗后色素沉着发生率的影响。
这项多中心、随机、对照研究纳入了101例静脉曲张患者(100名女性,1名男性;平均年龄46岁[范围25 - 68岁])。患者被分为两组,直径1毫米及以下的静脉为一组(第1组,n = 50),直径3毫米及以下的静脉为另一组(第2组,n = 51)。第1组用0.25%的聚多卡醇(STD)治疗,第2组用0.50%的STD治疗。在每位患者中,选择一个静脉曲张区域并分为两半。一半随机接受微血栓切除术,另一半作为对照。在治疗后1至3周对随机分组的一半进行微血栓切除术。在治疗前和治疗后16周获取标准照片,由三位对治疗分配不知情的独立评审员进行评估。每位评审员收到一套相同的研究区域治疗前和治疗后10×15厘米的彩色照片,并填写评分表。评分的平均值用于评估主要(色素沉着)和次要(总体临床改善)终点。采用配对t检验和卡方检验进行统计分析。
在第1组中,与对照侧相比,接受微血栓切除术的区域色素沉着在统计学上显著减少(P = 0.0047),总体临床改善评分更好(P = 0.0002)。在第2组中,两个区域之间没有显著差异,但患者报告硬化治疗后血栓性静脉炎相关的疼痛和炎症明显缓解。
对于直径1毫米及以下的静脉,微血栓切除术减少了色素沉着并改善了总体临床结果。对于直径3毫米及以下的静脉,未达到统计学显著性,但血栓切除术使硬化治疗后的疼痛和炎症更快消退。基于这些结果,建议在硬化治疗后进行微血栓切除术。