Rigatelli Gianluca, Docali Giorgio, Rossi Paolo, Bovolon Daniela, Rossi Daniele, Bandello Attilio, Lonardi Gabriele, Rigatelli Giorgio
EndoCardio Vascular Therapy Research, Department of Specialistic Medicine, Mater Salutis Legnago General Hospital, Legnago, Verona, Italy.
Int J Cardiovasc Imaging. 2003 Oct;19(5):361-6. doi: 10.1023/a:1025806908289.
Many fragmental classification of coronary artery anomalies (CAAs) exist, but a simple practical angiographic classification for angiographers has been never proposed. This study is aimed to suggest a simplified angiographic classification of congenital CAAs based on just a few univocal common angiographic patterns. The authors reviewed 5100 coronary angiographies in order to select CAAs patients and identify simple common angiographic features. Sixty-two patients (1.21%, female/male 20/42, mean age 65.3 +/- 10.6 years) had CAA on coronary angiography. The authors identified seven classes for seven angiographic patterns: I--hypoplasia/atresia, II--hyperdominance, III--fistula, IV--originating from wrong sinus, V--originating from other arteries, VI--splitting, and VII--tunnelling. A, P, B, R, L, PA, AO refer to anterior, posterior or passage between the aorta and pulmonary artery and to right, left, pulmonary artery and aorta. Three blind observers were be able to categorize all the CAAs according to this classification with no inter-observer differences: 3.2% were classified as class I, 8.1% as class II, 3.2% as class III, 24.2% as class IV, 22.5% as class V, 29% as class VI, and finally 9.7% as class VII. Eleven patients (17.7%) had 'A' passage, 10 (16.1%) 'P' passage and 9 (14.5%) 'B' passage. Twelve patients (19.5%) had anomalous origin from the right sinus of Valsalva, 2 (3.2%) from the left. This simplified classification was applicable to all most significant CAAs and in the authors' view it may make for a more rapid and univocal CAA angiographic description.
目前存在多种冠状动脉异常(CAA)的分类方法,但从未有过一种简单实用的、供血管造影师使用的血管造影分类法。本研究旨在基于几种明确的常见血管造影模式,提出一种简化的先天性CAA血管造影分类法。作者回顾了5100例冠状动脉造影,以筛选出CAA患者并确定简单的常见血管造影特征。62例患者(1.21%,女性/男性为20/42,平均年龄65.3±10.6岁)在冠状动脉造影中发现有CAA。作者根据七种血管造影模式确定了七类:I型——发育不全/闭锁,II型——优势过大,III型——瘘管,IV型——起源于错误的窦,V型——起源于其他动脉,VI型——分支,VII型——走行异常。A、P、B、R、L、PA、AO分别指前、后或主动脉与肺动脉之间的通道以及右、左、肺动脉和主动脉。三名盲法观察者能够根据该分类法对所有CAA进行分类,观察者间无差异:3.2%被分类为I类,8.1%为II类,3.2%为III类,24.2%为IV类,22.5%为V类,29%为VI类,最后9.7%为VII类。11例患者(17.7%)有“A”通道,10例(16.1%)有“P”通道,9例(14.5%)有“B”通道。12例患者(19.5%)起源于主动脉窦右窦,2例(3.2%)起源于左窦。这种简化分类适用于几乎所有重要的CAA,在作者看来,它可能使CAA血管造影描述更加快速和明确。