Rösler H, Birrer A, Lüscher D, Kinser J
Nuklearmedizinische Abteilung, Universität Bern, Inselspital.
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1992 Nov 28;122(48):1843-57.
545 patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma were followed up for periods ranging up to 25 years after first treatment (mean 8.1 years, 65% for over 5 years). 72% of patients with papillary carcinoma (n = 270), but only 52% with follicular carcinoma (n = 275) remained tumor-free during the further course. Residual malignancies persisted for more than the first year in 6% and 17% of patients respectively; there were tumor recurrences after an apparently tumor-free interval in 22% and 31% respectively, the latest after 12 and 27 years respectively. 6% and 19% of patients respectively died as a direct result of the tumor (and a group of equal size from other causes), half due to residual and half due to recurrent carcinoma. With regard to residual tumors, few significant risk factors were found preoperatively, comprising distant metastases (factor = 34 and 20 for papillary and follicular tumors respectively), age over 50 years (F = 6.4 and 5), infiltrating growth of primary tumor (F = 4 and 4.3), and regional lymph node involvement (F = 1.2 and 2). However, these factors were of little use in predicting the risk of the more frequently observed tumor recurrence, with maximum factors of 2 (for T4 and N+ stage) for papillary thyroid cancers and 1.5 for follicular cancers. At risk for recurrence were patients in whom total thyroidectomy was not performed (F = 2.3 and 2) and those who did not receive postoperative radioiodine treatment (F = 3), irrespective of age and tumor stage. Therefore, any individualizing regimen beginning with the first treatment has a bearing not only on residual tumor's 50% contribution to mortality. The equally large contribution of recurrences to tumor death can be influenced only by thyroidectomy or, more realistically, by strumectomy combined with early ablation of thyroid remnants with radioiodine. Postoperative radiotherapy of the neck region did not prevent tumor recurrence, and although hormonal suppression was never given the results compared well with the best of published long-term follow-up studies. There were no acute or late complications that could be ascribed to radioiodine treatment. However, a strict strategy of the reducing the administered doses was adopted: the ablation dose was half that used previously (1.5 GBq, i.e. 45 mCi on average), tumor treatment was halted even where residual uptake was observed scintigraphically (in 44% of patients treated) and radioiodine was no longer used for follow-up investigations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
545例分化型甲状腺癌患者在首次治疗后接受了长达25年的随访(平均8.1年,65%超过5年)。乳头状癌患者(n = 270)中有72%在后续病程中无瘤生存,而滤泡状癌患者(n = 275)中这一比例仅为52%。分别有6%和17%的患者残留恶性肿瘤持续超过1年;分别有22%和31%的患者在一段明显无瘤间期后出现肿瘤复发,最晚分别在12年和27年后复发。分别有6%和19%的患者直接死于肿瘤(另有一组规模相同的患者死于其他原因),其中一半死于残留肿瘤,一半死于复发性癌。关于残留肿瘤,术前发现的显著危险因素较少,包括远处转移(乳头状和滤泡状肿瘤的因素分别为34和20)、年龄超过50岁(F = 6.4和5)、原发肿瘤浸润性生长(F = 4和4.3)以及区域淋巴结受累(F = 1.2和2)。然而,这些因素在预测更常见的肿瘤复发风险方面作用不大,乳头状甲状腺癌的最大因素为2(T4和N+期),滤泡状癌为1.5。未行甲状腺全切术的患者(F = 2.3和2)以及未接受术后放射性碘治疗的患者(F = 3)有复发风险,与年龄和肿瘤分期无关。因此,从首次治疗开始的任何个体化方案不仅对残留肿瘤导致50%的死亡率有影响。复发对肿瘤死亡同样巨大的影响只能通过甲状腺切除术,或者更实际地说,通过甲状腺次全切除术联合早期用放射性碘消融甲状腺残余组织来加以影响。颈部区域的术后放疗并不能预防肿瘤复发,尽管从未给予激素抑制治疗,但结果与已发表的最佳长期随访研究相当。没有可归因于放射性碘治疗的急性或晚期并发症。然而,采取了严格的减少给药剂量策略:消融剂量是之前使用剂量的一半(1.5 GBq,即平均45 mCi),即使在闪烁扫描观察到残留摄取时(44%接受治疗的患者)也停止肿瘤治疗,并且不再使用放射性碘进行随访检查。(摘要截选至400字)