Lee Jeong Min, Jin Gong Yong, Goldberg S Nahum, Lee Yong Cheol, Chung Gyung Ho, Han Young Min, Lee Sang Yong, Kim Chong Soo
Departments of Radiology and Medicine, Chonbuk National University Hospital, South Korea.
Radiology. 2004 Jan;230(1):125-34. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2301020934. Epub 2003 Nov 26.
To assess technical feasibility, efficacy, and complications of percutaneous computed tomography (CT)-guided transthoracic radiofrequency (RF) ablation for treating inoperable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and lung metastases.
Twenty-six patients with 27 NSCLCs and four patients with five lung metastases underwent RF ablation with cooled-tip electrodes with CT guidance. Patients were not candidates for surgery because of either advanced-stage disease (n = 20) and/or comorbid processes (n = 4) or refusal to undergo surgery (n = 6). The procedure was performed with the intent to cure in 10 (33%) patients with stage I tumors and as palliative therapy in 20 (67%) patients. Contrast material-enhanced CT was performed immediately, 1 month, and then every 3 months after RF ablation to evaluate the response to therapy. Time to death for each patient was calculated with Kaplan-Meier analysis, and the effect of tumor size and the extent of coagulation necrosis on time to death were determined.
Complete necrosis was attained in 12 (38%) of 32 lesions; partial (>50%) necrosis, in the remaining 20 (62%) lesions. Tumor size was a major discriminator in achieving complete necrosis. Complete necrosis was attained in all six (100%) tumors smaller than 3 cm but only in six (23%) of 26 larger tumors (P <.05). Mean survival of patients with complete necrosis (19.7 months) was significantly better than that of patients with partial necrosis (8.7 months) (P <.01). There were three (in 30 patients, 10%) major complications, which included acute respiratory distress syndrome, and two pneumothoraces that required thoracostomy.
RF ablation appears to be a safe and promising procedure for the treatment of inoperable NSCLC and metastases.
评估经皮计算机断层扫描(CT)引导下经胸射频(RF)消融治疗不可切除的非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)及肺转移瘤的技术可行性、疗效及并发症。
26例患有27个NSCLC的患者及4例患有5个肺转移瘤的患者在CT引导下使用冷循环电极进行了RF消融。由于疾病晚期(n = 20)和/或合并症(n = 4)或拒绝手术(n = 6),这些患者不适合手术。该手术旨在治愈10例(33%)I期肿瘤患者,并作为20例(67%)患者的姑息治疗。RF消融后立即、1个月后以及之后每3个月进行对比剂增强CT检查,以评估治疗反应。采用Kaplan-Meier分析计算每位患者的死亡时间,并确定肿瘤大小和凝固性坏死范围对死亡时间的影响。
32个病灶中有12个(38%)实现了完全坏死;其余20个(62%)病灶为部分(>50%)坏死。肿瘤大小是实现完全坏死的主要判别因素。所有6个(100%)小于3 cm的肿瘤均实现了完全坏死,但26个较大肿瘤中只有6个(23%)实现了完全坏死(P <.05)。完全坏死患者的平均生存期(19.7个月)明显优于部分坏死患者(仅8.7个月)(P <.01)。有3例(30例患者中的10%)主要并发症,包括急性呼吸窘迫综合征,以及2例需要胸腔造口术的气胸。
RF消融似乎是治疗不可切除的NSCLC及转移瘤的一种安全且有前景的方法。