Simard Marie, Beaudry Madeleine, Drapeau Sylvie, Nadeau France, Charbonneau Cécile
Université Laval.
Can J Commun Ment Health. 2002 Summer(4 Suppl):131-51.
In this study, similarities and differences in sibling relationships between children who have experienced family transitions and those who have not are examined. Comparisons are made between children who live in intact families, those whose parents have separated, and those who live in substitute care regarding the quality of their relationships with one of their siblings. More specifically, 4 dimensions describing the quality of sibling relationships are compared: Warmth/Closeness, Conflict, Relative Status/Power, and Rivalry (Furman & Buhrmester, 1985). The sample is made up of 3 groups of children (N = 158) aged between 8 and 12 years old: children living in intact families (n = 101), children who have experienced parental separation (n = 35), and children living in substitute care (n = 22). Results indicate differences on dimensions of Warmth/Closeness, Conflict, and Relative Status/Power. Different patterns of responses between the children who have experienced family transitions and those who have not are observed for the dimensions of Conflict and Power. The significant difference observed between the groups for the dimension of Warmth appears difficult to explain. Discussion of these results emphasizes the importance of the relationship between brothers and sisters experiencing family transition.
在本研究中,我们考察了经历过家庭变迁的儿童与未经历过家庭变迁的儿童在手足关系上的异同。我们对生活在完整家庭中的儿童、父母已离异的儿童以及生活在替代照料环境中的儿童与其兄弟姐妹之一的关系质量进行了比较。更具体地说,我们比较了描述手足关系质量的四个维度:温暖/亲密、冲突、相对地位/权力和竞争(弗曼和布尔梅斯特,1985年)。样本由三组8至12岁的儿童(N = 158)组成:生活在完整家庭中的儿童(n = 101)、经历过父母离异的儿童(n = 35)和生活在替代照料环境中的儿童(n = 22)。结果表明,在温暖/亲密、冲突和相对地位/权力维度上存在差异。在冲突和权力维度上,观察到经历过家庭变迁的儿童与未经历过家庭变迁的儿童有不同的反应模式。在温暖维度上,各组之间观察到的显著差异似乎难以解释。对这些结果的讨论强调了经历家庭变迁的兄弟姐妹之间关系的重要性。