Rutten G, van der Laan J
Department of the Standard Setting Programme, Nederlands Huisartsen Genootschap, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Br J Gen Pract. 1992 Oct;42(363):411-4.
Since 1989 the Dutch college of general practitioners (Nederlands Huisartsen Genootschap) has published a total of 22 standards on different subjects. For the standard on hypercholesterolaemia a working conference was organized and attended by the most active general practitioners in the college. The conference aimed to facilitate the publication of a well balanced standard and to judge the value of the previously used procedure in which the draft standard was sent to a sample of college members for their comments on the feasibility of the guidelines. Six controversial areas of hypercholesterolaemia were discussed at the conference and the conclusions reached were compared with the opinions of the random sample responding to the postal questionnaire. The representativeness of the populations consulted and the impact of the conference on the standard were also studied. Compared with the total population of Dutch general practitioners, women and those in the youngest age group (30-35 years) were over-represented in the random sample, while at the conference general practitioners from two partner and group practices were over-represented. There were no significant differences in background characteristics between the 36 conference participants and the 52 respondents to the written inquiry. Their opinions differed on the appropriateness of an upper age limit for screening for hypercholesterolaemia and on whether the 'average' general practitioner can prescribe a cholesterol-lowering diet. The results of the conference appear to have altered the final text of the standard on four issues: screening in women, having an upper age limit for screening, the time period for blood sampling and the prescription of a cholesterol-lowering diet by the general practitioner.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
自1989年以来,荷兰全科医生学院(Nederlands Huisartsen Genootschap)已就不同主题发布了共计22项标准。针对高胆固醇血症标准,学院组织了一次工作会议,最活跃的全科医生参加了此次会议。该会议旨在推动发布一项均衡的标准,并评判此前使用的程序的价值,在该程序中,标准草案被发送给学院成员样本,以征求他们对指南可行性的意见。会议讨论了高胆固醇血症的六个有争议领域,并将得出的结论与回复邮政调查问卷的随机样本的意见进行了比较。还研究了所咨询人群的代表性以及会议对标准的影响。与荷兰全科医生的总体人群相比,随机样本中女性和最年轻年龄组(30 - 35岁)的人占比过高,而在会议上,来自两家合伙诊所和团体诊所的全科医生占比过高。36名会议参与者和52名书面询问回复者在背景特征方面没有显著差异。他们在高胆固醇血症筛查的年龄上限的适宜性以及“普通”全科医生是否可以开出降胆固醇饮食处方的问题上存在不同意见。会议结果似乎在四个问题上改变了标准的最终文本:女性筛查、筛查的年龄上限、采血时间段以及全科医生开出降胆固醇饮食处方。(摘要截选至250字)