Sommerfeld Disa K, Eek Elsy U-B, Svensson Anna-Karin, Holmqvist Lotta Widén, von Arbin Magnus H
Department of Geriatric Medicine, Danderyd Hospital, Danderyd, Sweden.
Stroke. 2004 Jan;35(1):134-9. doi: 10.1161/01.STR.0000105386.05173.5E. Epub 2003 Dec 18.
There is no consensus concerning the number of patients developing spasticity or the relationship between spasticity and disabilities after acute stroke. The aim of the present study was to describe the extent to which spasticity occurs and is associated with disabilities (motor impairments and activity limitations).
Ninety-five patients with first-ever stroke were examined initially (mean, 5.4 days) and 3 months after stroke with the Modified Ashworth Scale for spasticity; self-reported muscle stiffness; tendon reflexes; Birgitta Lindmark motor performance; Nine Hole Peg Test for manual dexterity; Rivermead Mobility Index; Get-Up and Go test; and Barthel Index.
Of the 95 patients studied, 64 were hemiparetic, 18 were spastic, 6 reported muscle stiffness, and 18 had increased tendon reflexes 3 months after stroke. Patients who were nonspastic (n=77) had statistically significantly better motor and activity scores than spastic patients (n=18). However, the correlations between muscle tone and disability scores were low, and severe disabilities were seen in almost the same number of nonspastic as spastic patients.
Although spasticity seems to contribute to disabilities after stroke, spasticity was present in only 19% of the patients investigated 3 months after stroke. Severe disabilities were seen in almost the same number of nonspastic as spastic patients. These findings indicate that the focus on spasticity in stroke rehabilitation is out of step with its clinical importance. Careful and continual evaluation to establish the cause of the patient's disabilities is essential before a decision is made on the most proper rehabilitation approach.
关于急性卒中后发生痉挛的患者数量,或痉挛与残疾之间的关系,目前尚无共识。本研究的目的是描述痉挛发生的程度及其与残疾(运动障碍和活动受限)之间的关联。
对95例首次发生卒中的患者在发病初期(平均5.4天)和卒中后3个月进行检查,评估指标包括改良Ashworth痉挛评定量表、自我报告的肌肉僵硬程度、腱反射、Birgitta Lindmark运动表现、用于评估手部灵巧性的九孔插板试验、Rivermead活动指数、起身行走试验和Barthel指数。
在研究的95例患者中,64例为偏瘫,18例有痉挛,6例报告有肌肉僵硬,18例在卒中后3个月腱反射增强。非痉挛患者(n = 77)的运动和活动评分在统计学上显著优于痉挛患者(n = 18)。然而,肌张力与残疾评分之间的相关性较低,非痉挛患者和痉挛患者中出现严重残疾的人数几乎相同。
尽管痉挛似乎会导致卒中后的残疾,但在卒中后3个月接受调查的患者中,仅有19%存在痉挛。非痉挛患者和痉挛患者中出现严重残疾的人数几乎相同。这些发现表明,卒中康复中对痉挛的关注与其临床重要性并不相符。在决定最恰当的康复方法之前,仔细且持续地评估以确定患者残疾的原因至关重要。