Ertmer David J, Strong Lynette M, Sadagopan Neeraja
Audiology and Speech Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47909, USA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2003 Apr;46(2):328-40. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2003/026).
This longitudinal case study examined the emergence of a wide range of oral language skills in a deaf child whose cochlear implant was activated at 20 months. The main purposes of this study were to determine "Hannah's" rate of spoken language development during her second to fourth year of implant experience and to estimate the efficiency of her progress by comparing her performance to that of typically developing children. Mother-child interactions were also examined to determine changes in Hannah's communication competence. Normal or above-normal rates of development were observed in the following areas: (a) decreased production of nonwords, (b) increased receptive vocabulary, (c) type-token ratio, (d) regular use of word combinations, and (e) comprehension of phrases. Below-normal rates of development were observed in the following areas: (a) speech intelligibility, (b) number of word types and tokens, and (c) mean length of utterance in morphemes. Analysis of parent-child interactions showed a large increase in responses to questions during the third year of implant use. Data from Hannah's first post-implantation year (D. J. Ertmer & J. A. Mellon, 2001) indicated that some early language milestones were attained quite rapidly (e.g., canonical vocalizations and emergence of first word combinations). In contrast, the current study revealed that progress had slowed for related, but more advanced skills (e.g., production of intelligible speech and consistent use of word combinations). These changes in rate of development suggest that any advantages for language learning due to Hannah's advanced maturity (or other unknown factors) decreased with time and increasing linguistic complexity.
这项纵向案例研究考察了一名20个月大时激活人工耳蜗的失聪儿童多种口语技能的出现情况。本研究的主要目的是确定“汉娜”在植入人工耳蜗后的第二年至第四年期间的口语发展速度,并通过将她的表现与正常发育儿童的表现进行比较,来评估她进步的效率。同时还考察了母婴互动情况,以确定汉娜沟通能力的变化。在以下方面观察到正常或高于正常的发展速度:(a)无意义词的产生减少;(b)接受性词汇增加;(c)类型-标志比;(d)单词组合的常规使用;(e)短语理解。在以下方面观察到低于正常的发展速度:(a)言语可懂度;(b)单词类型和标志的数量;(c)语素平均语句长度。对亲子互动的分析表明,在植入人工耳蜗使用的第三年,对问题的回应大幅增加。来自汉娜植入人工耳蜗后第一年的数据(D. J. 厄特默和J. A. 梅隆,2001年)表明,一些早期语言里程碑达成得相当迅速(例如,规范发声和第一个单词组合的出现)。相比之下,当前研究表明,相关但更高级技能的进步已经放缓(例如,可懂言语的产生和单词组合的持续使用)。发展速度的这些变化表明,由于汉娜早熟(或其他未知因素)而带来的语言学习优势随着时间推移和语言复杂性增加而减少。