Gex-Fabry Marianne, Balant-Gorgia Androniki E, Balant Luc P, Rudaz Serge, Veuthey Jean-Luc, Bertschy Gilles
Clinical Research Unit, Department of Psychiatry, 2 chemin du Petit-Bel-Air, 1225 Chêne-Bourg, Switzerland.
Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 2004 Feb;59(12):883-91. doi: 10.1007/s00228-003-0710-3. Epub 2003 Dec 24.
Early clinical response to antidepressant treatment is an important therapeutic goal, considering the psychological, social and economic consequences of depression. The aim of the present study was to investigate the relationship between the time course of response and the concentration of venlafaxine (V), its active metabolite O-desmethylvenlafaxine (ODV) and enantiomeric ratios V(+)/V(-) and ODV(+)/ODV(-).
Depressed inpatients ( n=35) received V orally at a fixed 300 mg daily dose. Accepted comedication included clorazepate (maximum 60 mg/day), zopiclone (maximum 15 mg/day) and low-dose trazodone (maximum 200 mg/day). Severity of depression was assessed on days 0, 4, 7, 11, 14, 21 and 28 (Montgomery and Asberg Depression Rating Scale). Blood samples were taken on day 14 and day 28 and submitted to stereoselective determination. All measurements reflected trough steady-state values. First, pattern analysis was used to provide a categorical perspective of clinical response (50% improvement from baseline depression score). Patients displaying non-response, transient response, early persistent response and delayed persistent response were compared with respect to racemic concentrations and enantiomeric ratios. Second, in a dimensional perspective, mixed-effects modelling was used to analyse severity of depression versus time curves with respect to the possible influence of concentrations and enantiomeric ratios.
Comparison of patients with and without persistent response did not reveal any significant difference for V, ODV, V+ODV plasma levels or enantiomeric ratios. Persistent response was significantly associated with less frequent pre-study antidepressant medication and less frequent comedication with zopiclone (day 14) and clorazepate (day 28) during the study. Focus on patients with persistent response ( n=19, 54.3%) indicated that early response, first observed before day 14, was associated with significantly higher V+ODV concentration than delayed response (median 725 ng/ml versus 554 ng/ml, P=0.023). No difference was found for pre-study medication or comedication during the study. Shorter time to onset of response was significantly associated with lower V(+)/V(-) enantiomeric ratio (r(s)=0.48, P<0.05). Mixed-effects modelling of depression severity versus time curves in patients with persistent response confirmed that either higher V+ODV plasma level or lower V(+)/V(-) ratio were significantly associated with more rapid decrease of depression score (likelihood ratio tests, P=0.012 and P=0.046, respectively).
Considering its modest sample size, naturalistic design and limited observation period, the present study provided preliminary indication that earlier clinical response may occur with higher V+ODV plasma level, extending previous dose-response studies. The hypothesis was also raised that exposure to a more potent noradrenergic therapeutic moiety, as reflected by a lower V(+)/V(-) ratio, may be relevant to early improvement of depression.
考虑到抑郁症的心理、社会和经济后果,抗抑郁治疗的早期临床反应是一个重要的治疗目标。本研究的目的是调查反应的时间进程与文拉法辛(V)及其活性代谢物O-去甲基文拉法辛(ODV)的浓度以及对映体比率V(+)/V(-)和ODV(+)/ODV(-)之间的关系。
35例抑郁症住院患者每天口服固定剂量300mg的V。允许合用的药物包括氯氮卓(最大剂量60mg/天)、佐匹克隆(最大剂量15mg/天)和低剂量曲唑酮(最大剂量200mg/天)。在第0、4、7、11、14、21和28天评估抑郁严重程度(蒙哥马利-阿斯伯格抑郁评定量表)。在第14天和第28天采集血样并进行立体选择性测定。所有测量反映谷值稳态值。首先,采用模式分析从分类角度提供临床反应(与基线抑郁评分相比改善50%)。比较无反应、短暂反应、早期持续反应和延迟持续反应的患者的外消旋体浓度和对映体比率。其次,从维度角度,使用混合效应模型分析抑郁严重程度与时间曲线,考虑浓度和对映体比率的可能影响。
有持续反应和无持续反应的患者在V、ODV、V + ODV血浆水平或对映体比率方面没有显著差异。持续反应与研究前较少使用抗抑郁药物以及研究期间较少合用佐匹克隆(第14天)和氯氮卓(第28天)显著相关。关注有持续反应的患者(n = 19,54.3%)表明,在第14天之前首次观察到的早期反应与显著更高的V + ODV浓度相关,而延迟反应的V + ODV浓度较低(中位数725 ng/ml对554 ng/ml,P = 0.023)。在研究前用药或研究期间合用药物方面没有发现差异。反应开始时间较短与较低的V(+)/V(-)对映体比率显著相关(r(s)=0.48,P < 0.05)。对有持续反应患者的抑郁严重程度与时间曲线进行混合效应模型分析证实,较高的V + ODV血浆水平或较低的V(+)/V(-)比率均与抑郁评分更快下降显著相关(似然比检验,P分别为0.012和0.046)。
考虑到本研究样本量适中、自然主义设计和观察期有限,本研究提供了初步迹象,表明较高的V + ODV血浆水平可能会出现更早的临床反应,扩展了先前的剂量反应研究。还提出了一个假设,即较低的V(+)/V(-)比率所反映的更有效的去甲肾上腺素能治疗部分的暴露可能与抑郁症的早期改善有关。