Shamai S, Coambs R B
Golan Research Institute, Qazrin, Israel.
Adolescence. 1992 Winter;27(108):757-70.
This paper evaluates intervention programs in schools using the theoretical framework of the critical sociology of education, and most specifically, the extent to which schools are autonomous from the larger society. Three different types of intervention programs are reviewed: drug abuse prevention, sex education, and programs to change gender stereotypes, all of which were found to have limited effectiveness. Schools appear unable to change behaviors which are prevalent in a culture because they themselves are strongly influenced by that culture, and because adolescents are influenced by forces outside school. To be effective, such interventions would seem to require governmental agencies, community groups, and the media to work with the schools in order to influence the culture and thus produce behavioral changes in individuals.
本文运用教育批判社会学的理论框架评估学校中的干预项目,具体而言,评估学校在多大程度上独立于大社会。本文回顾了三种不同类型的干预项目:药物滥用预防、性教育以及改变性别刻板印象的项目,所有这些项目的效果都有限。学校似乎无法改变一种文化中普遍存在的行为,因为学校自身受到那种文化的强烈影响,也因为青少年受到校外力量的影响。为了取得成效,此类干预似乎需要政府机构、社区团体和媒体与学校合作,以影响文化,从而促使个体行为发生改变。