Shalev Arieh Y, Tuval-Mashiach Rivka, Hadar Hilit
Center for Traumatic Stress, Kiryat Hadassah, Israel.
J Clin Psychiatry. 2004;65 Suppl 1:4-10.
There is a large body of literature on the psychological consequences of trauma experienced by individuals, but there are few studies of the acute and long-term effects of mass trauma on victimized communities. Acute stress reactions are expected, and overall resilience in the aftermath of major disasters is the rule rather than the exception. However, the available literature on mass trauma suggests that certain factors may provide clues to identifying persons at greater risk for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The severity of the trauma and the accessibility of support systems may affect long-term outcome. In industrialized countries, mass violence caused by malicious human intent may be a more virulent precursor to PTSD than other types of mass trauma, such as technological or natural disasters. School-aged children, women, persons with existing psychiatric illness, those who experienced significant losses or threat to life, those who have insufficient psychological and social support systems, and persons who exhibit symptoms of functional impairment may be at greater risk for PTSD. The findings of a population study of 2 traumatized communities are discussed. Early intervention in communities suffering mass trauma should consist of general support and bolstering of the recovery environment rather than psychological treatment; some forms of early psychological interventions may worsen outcome. There is a great unmet need for treatment and intervention guidelines for victims of mass trauma, and well-designed studies are warranted.
关于个体经历创伤的心理后果已有大量文献,但针对群体创伤对受灾社区的急性和长期影响的研究却很少。急性应激反应是可以预期的,而且在重大灾难之后总体恢复力是常态而非例外。然而,现有关于群体创伤的文献表明,某些因素可能为识别创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)风险更高的人群提供线索。创伤的严重程度和支持系统的可及性可能会影响长期结果。在工业化国家,由恶意人类意图导致的大规模暴力可能比其他类型的群体创伤(如技术或自然灾害)更易引发PTSD。学龄儿童、女性、已有精神疾病的人、经历过重大生命损失或生命受到威胁的人、心理和社会支持系统不足的人以及表现出功能障碍症状的人可能患PTSD的风险更高。本文讨论了对两个受灾社区进行的一项群体研究的结果。对遭受群体创伤的社区进行早期干预应包括提供一般支持和改善恢复环境,而非心理治疗;某些形式的早期心理干预可能会使结果恶化。对于群体创伤受害者的治疗和干预指南存在巨大的未满足需求,则有必要开展精心设计的研究。