Manchanda Rahul, Malla Ashok, Harricharan Rajendra, Cortese Leonardo, Takhar Jatinder
University of Western Ontario, Dept of Psychiatry, London.
Can J Psychiatry. 2003 Dec;48(11):722-6. doi: 10.1177/070674370304801103.
There is widespread consensus that the EEG is not useful for the detection of clinically relevant abnormalities in patients with psychosis. Given that the EEG records brain dysfunction, this study examines whether an abnormal EEG in first-episode psychosis patients is associated with poorer prognosis, compared with a normal EEG.
At their initial assessment, 61 patients with first-episode psychosis had an EEG classified according to the following modified Mayo Clinic system: normal, essentially normal (that is, one or more elements of questionable normality), or dysrhythmia (grade I to V). We assessed psychiatric symptoms using the Scale for Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS) and the Scale for Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS) on entry and after 1 year of treatment. Psychosis is considered to have remitted if there are no, or minimal, psychotic symptoms (that is, a rating of 2 or less on every SAPS global rating), maintained for 1 month.
At the end of 1 year, 19/21 (90.5%) patients with a normal EEG had a remission of their positive symptoms, compared with 18/28 (64.3%) of those with an essentially normal EEG and only 7/12 (58.3%) of those with dysrhythmia. Negative symptoms were reduced by more than 50% in 11/18 (61.1%) patients with a normal EEG, compared with 10/28 (35.7%) patients with an essentially normal EEG. None of the 8 patients with dysrhythmia on their EEG experienced reduced negative symptoms.
The above findings suggest that an abnormal EEG in patients with first-episode psychosis is associated with a poorer prognosis.
人们普遍认为脑电图对检测精神病患者临床相关异常并无用处。鉴于脑电图记录的是脑功能障碍,本研究旨在探讨首发精神病患者脑电图异常与脑电图正常者相比,是否与预后较差相关。
在首次评估时,61例首发精神病患者的脑电图根据以下改良梅奥诊所系统进行分类:正常、基本正常(即存在一个或多个可疑正常的元素)或节律紊乱(I至V级)。我们在入组时和治疗1年后使用阴性症状评估量表(SANS)和阳性症状评估量表(SAPS)评估精神症状。如果没有或仅有轻微的精神病症状(即SAPS总体评分每项为2分或更低)且持续1个月,则认为精神病已缓解。
在1年结束时,脑电图正常的患者中有19/21(90.5%)阳性症状得到缓解,而脑电图基本正常的患者中这一比例为18/28(64.3%),脑电图节律紊乱的患者中仅为7/12(58.3%)。脑电图正常的患者中有11/18(61.1%)阴性症状减少了50%以上,而脑电图基本正常的患者中这一比例为10/28(35.7%)。脑电图节律紊乱的8例患者中无一例阴性症状减轻。
上述研究结果表明,首发精神病患者脑电图异常与预后较差相关。