Sandberg David I, Bilsky Mark H, Kushner Brian H, Souweidane Mark M, Kramer Kim, Laquaglia Michael P, Panageas Katherine S, Cheung Nai-Kong V
Department of Surgery, Division of Neurosurgery, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, 1275 York Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10021, USA.
Pediatr Neurosurg. 2003 Dec;39(6):291-8. doi: 10.1159/000075256.
Considerable controversy exists regarding the appropriate management of spinal involvement in neuroblastoma (NB) patients. We review a large group of such patients and offer treatment recommendations.
Forty-six patients with epidural and/or neural foraminal involvement treated between 1987 and 1998 were staged according to the International NB Staging System (INSS) and classified as high-risk (INSS stage 4; n = 31) or low-risk (INSS stage <4; n = 15). Of 13 high- risk patients with normal neurologic examinations and no radiographic high-grade spinal cord compression (HGSCC), 12 were treated initially with chemotherapy, and only 1 demonstrated neurologic deterioration. HGSCC was present in 18 patients with high-risk NB; 7 of 10 (70%) treated initially with chemotherapy and 6 of 6 (100%) managed initially with operation improved or remained stable. All 9 low-risk patients with normal neurologic examinations and no HGSCC remained neurologically intact following operations (n = 7) or chemotherapy (n = 2). All 4 low-risk patients with HGSCC treated with operations improved or remained stable, and 0 of 2 (0%) low-risk patients treated initially with chemotherapy remained stable. Spinal deformities occurred in 2 of 16 patients (12.5%) treated nonoperatively and in 9 of 30 (30.0%) who underwent operations.
High-risk NB patients with spinal involvement but normal neurologic examinations should be offered chemotherapy. High-risk patients with HGSCC may respond to chemotherapy, but a small percentage will require operations for progressive neurologic deficits. Chemotherapy may be avoided in low-risk patients who are offered potentially curative operations. Patients treated with operations for epidural disease are at high risk of subsequently developing spinal deformity.
对于神经母细胞瘤(NB)患者脊柱受累的恰当治疗,存在相当大的争议。我们回顾了一大组此类患者并给出治疗建议。
1987年至1998年间接受治疗的46例硬膜外和/或椎间孔受累患者,根据国际NB分期系统(INSS)进行分期,并分为高危组(INSS 4期;n = 31)或低危组(INSS分期<4期;n = 15)。13例神经学检查正常且无影像学高级别脊髓压迫(HGSCC)的高危患者中,12例最初接受化疗,仅1例出现神经功能恶化。18例高危NB患者存在HGSCC;10例中7例(70%)最初接受化疗,6例(100%)最初接受手术治疗的患者病情改善或保持稳定。所有9例神经学检查正常且无HGSCC的低危患者,在接受手术(n = 7)或化疗(n = 2)后神经功能均保持完好。所有4例接受手术治疗的HGSCC低危患者病情改善或保持稳定,2例最初接受化疗的低危患者中0例病情保持稳定。16例非手术治疗的患者中有2例(12.5%)出现脊柱畸形,30例接受手术的患者中有9例(30.0%)出现脊柱畸形。
脊柱受累但神经学检查正常的高危NB患者应接受化疗。伴有HGSCC的高危患者可能对化疗有反应,但一小部分患者因进行性神经功能缺损需要手术治疗。对于可进行潜在治愈性手术的低危患者,可避免化疗。因硬膜外疾病接受手术治疗的患者随后发生脊柱畸形的风险很高。