Park Jin-Hoon, Wilde Heather, Shea Charles H
Department of Health and Kinesiology, Texas A&M University, USA.
J Mot Behav. 2004 Mar;36(1):51-61. doi: 10.3200/JMBR.36.1.51-61.
A 16-element movement sequence was taught under part-whole and whole-practice conditions. Participants (N = 18) produced a right-arm lever movement to sequentially presented target locations. The authors constructed part-whole practice by providing practice on only the 1st 8 elements on the 1st day of practice (100 repetitions of the 8-element sequence) and on all 16 elements on the 2nd day of practice (100 repetitions of the 16-element sequence). The whole-practice group practiced all 16 elements on both days (100 repetitions of the 16-element sequence per day). No differences in sequence structure or in movement duration of the 16-element sequence were noted on the retention test (Day 3). On transfer tests in which the 1st and last 8 elements were tested separately, however, the participants in the part-whole practice group performed more quickly than the participants in the whole-practice group, especially on the last 8 elements. Participants in the whole-practice group appeared to code the sequence so that it was relatively difficult to fully partition it into separate movements. Thus, on the transfer tests, there continued to be residual effects of the 8 elements that did not have to be produced but slowed down the rate of responding for the whole-practice group. That finding was not observed for the part-whole practice group.
在部分-整体练习和整体练习条件下教授了一个包含16个元素的动作序列。参与者(N = 18)进行右臂杠杆动作,以依次到达呈现的目标位置。作者通过在练习的第一天仅对前8个元素进行练习(8元素序列重复100次),并在练习的第二天对所有16个元素进行练习(16元素序列重复100次)来构建部分-整体练习。整体练习组在两天内都对所有16个元素进行练习(每天16元素序列重复100次)。在保持测试(第3天)中,未发现16元素序列的序列结构或动作持续时间存在差异。然而,在分别测试前8个和后8个元素的迁移测试中,部分-整体练习组的参与者比整体练习组的参与者表现得更快,尤其是在后8个元素上。整体练习组的参与者似乎对序列进行了编码,以至于将其完全划分为单独的动作相对困难。因此,在迁移测试中,对于整体练习组,那些不必执行但减慢了反应速度的8个元素仍有残留影响。部分-整体练习组未观察到这一现象。