Thomas David, Royle Ian, John Jeyanthi H, Bainton Peter
Cherwell Vale Primary Care Trust, Oxfordshire, UK.
Prim Dent Care. 2004 Jan;11(1):26-30. doi: 10.1308/135576104322702804.
To investigate the quality of information in referrals for patients aged under 16 years referred for dental extraction under general anaesthesia (GA), to ascertain the knowledge and expectations of the parents of these patients, and to determine whether the number of teeth extracted in secondary care coincides with that of the referring dentist.
Retrospective study of referrals of all patients aged under 16 years referred to community dental clinics in Berkshire, Buckinghamshire, Northamptonshire and Oxfordshire over a 26-day period.
The majority (62.2%) of the 251 referrals examined were for extractions under GA. Of these, 125 were by letter and 117 using a pro forma. Significantly more pro formas (33) than letters (8) contained a full medical history (P < 0.001). A treatment plan was included in significantly more pro formas (76) than letters (49) (P < 0.01). Few referrals contained a note about the discussion of alternatives to a GA procedure and only 37% (58/156) of parents reported that the referring general dental practitioner had discussed alternative treatments with them. A total of 551 primary teeth were indicated for removal but 846 teeth were eventually removed.
Our findings indicate a need for parents of patients referred for GA procedures to be better informed about alternatives. Improvement in the quality of referrals, perhaps with the aid of standard pro formas, would also facilitate more effective management of referred patients.
调查16岁以下因需全身麻醉(GA)拔牙而转诊患者的转诊信息质量,确定这些患者父母的认知和期望,并确定二级医疗机构拔除的牙齿数量是否与转诊牙医记录的一致。
对伯克郡、白金汉郡、北安普敦郡和牛津郡社区牙科诊所26天内转诊的所有16岁以下患者进行回顾性研究。
在检查的251份转诊病例中,大多数(62.2%)是因需全身麻醉拔牙。其中,125份是通过信函转诊,117份使用了表格。包含完整病史的表格(33份)明显多于信函(8份)(P<0.001)。包含治疗计划的表格(76份)明显多于信函(49份)(P<0.01)。很少有转诊病例包含关于讨论全身麻醉替代方案的记录,只有37%(58/156)的家长表示转诊的普通牙科医生与他们讨论过替代治疗方案。共指出需要拔除551颗乳牙,但最终拔除了846颗牙齿。
我们的研究结果表明,对于因全身麻醉转诊的患者,需要让其父母更好地了解替代方案。或许借助标准表格来提高转诊信息质量,也将有助于更有效地管理转诊患者。