Demers C, Ginsberg J S, Hirsh J, Henderson P, Blajchman M A
McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Ann Intern Med. 1992 May 1;116(9):754-61. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-116-9-754.
To estimate the prevalence of objectively proven thrombotic complications in antithrombin-III-deficient persons.
Cross-sectional study and a critical review of the literature.
The prevalence of thrombosis in antithrombin III-deficient and -nondeficient family members of a large kindred was estimated by history, review of diagnostic tests, and examination for venous reflux by Doppler ultrasonography, as an indicator of previous venous thrombosis. A MEDLINE search and literature review of the published English- and French-language literature from 1966 to 1990 that described antithrombin-III-deficient families was done, and the following information was obtained: the prevalence of thrombosis in deficient and nondeficient family members, the presence or absence of risk factors for thrombosis (surgery, pregnancy, the postpartum state, use of oral contraceptives, immobilization, metastatic cancer, major trauma) at the time of the thrombotic event, and age of onset of the first episode of thrombosis. The validity of the studies was assessed according to predetermined criteria.
Sixty-seven research subjects were evaluated. Six of 31 (19.4%) antithrombin-III-deficient subjects compared with none of 36 (0%) nondeficient subjects had had one or more thrombotic events. The initial episode in five of six subjects had occurred in association with risk factors for thrombosis. The literature search indicated that the pooled prevalence of symptomatic venous thrombosis among the deficient subjects was 51%, but objective testing was done in only 17% of these subjects at the time of presentation.
Based on the data from this antithrombin-III-deficient kindred, lifelong anticoagulant prophylaxis does not appear to be warranted in asymptomatic carriers, and prophylaxis could be limited to periods of high risk for thrombosis.
评估抗凝血酶III缺乏者中经客观证实的血栓形成并发症的患病率。
横断面研究及对文献的批判性综述。
通过病史、诊断检查回顾以及多普勒超声检查静脉反流情况(作为既往静脉血栓形成的指标),评估一个大家族中抗凝血酶III缺乏和不缺乏的家庭成员的血栓形成患病率。对1966年至1990年期间发表的描述抗凝血酶III缺乏家族的英文和法语文献进行了MEDLINE检索及文献综述,获取了以下信息:缺乏和不缺乏的家庭成员中的血栓形成患病率、血栓形成事件发生时是否存在血栓形成的危险因素(手术、妊娠、产后状态、口服避孕药的使用、制动、转移性癌症、重大创伤)以及首次血栓形成发作的发病年龄。根据预定标准评估研究的有效性。
评估了67名研究对象。31名抗凝血酶III缺乏的对象中有6名(19.4%)发生过一次或多次血栓形成事件,而36名不缺乏的对象中无一例(0%)发生过。6名对象中有5名的首次发作与血栓形成的危险因素有关。文献检索表明,缺乏者中有症状的静脉血栓形成的合并患病率为51%,但在这些对象就诊时只有17%进行了客观检查。
根据这个抗凝血酶III缺乏家族的数据,对于无症状携带者似乎没有必要进行终身抗凝预防,预防可限于血栓形成的高危期。