Gimeno David, Benavides Fernando G, Mira Miquel, Martinez José Miguel, Benach Joan
Occupational Health Research Unit, Department of Health and Experimental Sciences, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, India.
J Occup Health. 2004 Jan;46(1):43-8. doi: 10.1539/joh.46.43.
Psychosocial risk factors have been considered as characteristics of the work environment rather than an individual issue, but their presence in the workplace is usually measured by self-reported questionnaires, based on worker attitudes. The objective of the study was to compare a self-reported measure of psychological job demands in a bus driver sample with selected indicators of bus company activity, as external 'objective' indicators, in order to assess its external validity. The final sample included 713 drivers in 41 routes. Self-reported measures of psychosocial work risk factors were obtained by the Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ). Four external indicators were available for each route: passengers, break times, bus incidents, and regulating actions. Spearman's correlation coefficient was estimated to assess the validity. Correlation coefficients showed that self-reported psychological demands were statistically significant correlated (p<0.05) with two external indicators: bus incidents (rho=0.397), and regulating actions (rho=0.475). Self-reported psychosocial risk factors have been compared with independent external indicators of the psychosocial work environment, trying to avoid any subject's perception. According to our results, psychological demands measured by the JCQ seem to reflect the actual psychosocial work environment. Other studies are necessary to confirm these results and to assess job control and job social support. This would be another step in improving our knowledge of the quality of measurement of psychosocial risk factors.
社会心理风险因素一直被视为工作环境的特征而非个人问题,但它们在工作场所的存在通常是通过基于员工态度的自我报告问卷来衡量的。本研究的目的是将公交司机样本中自我报告的心理工作需求测量结果与公交公司活动的选定指标(作为外部“客观”指标)进行比较,以评估其外部效度。最终样本包括41条线路上的713名司机。通过工作内容问卷(JCQ)获得社会心理工作风险因素的自我报告测量结果。每条线路有四个外部指标:乘客数量、休息时间、公交事故和监管行动。估计斯皮尔曼相关系数以评估效度。相关系数表明,自我报告的心理需求与两个外部指标在统计学上显著相关(p<0.05):公交事故(rho=0.397)和监管行动(rho=0.475)。已将自我报告的社会心理风险因素与社会心理工作环境的独立外部指标进行比较,尽量避免任何主观认知。根据我们的结果,JCQ测量的心理需求似乎反映了实际的社会心理工作环境。需要其他研究来证实这些结果,并评估工作控制和工作社会支持。这将是提高我们对社会心理风险因素测量质量认识的又一步。