Fabrega H
University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, PA 15213.
Soc Sci Med. 1992 Jul;35(1):91-103. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(92)90122-7.
A medical theory of phenomena thought of as psychiatric would rely on concepts and seek explanations that pertain to the concerns of biomedicine. A social theory of the psychiatric needs concepts and seeks explanations that pertain to concerns of the social and cultural sciences. Some of the requirements of such a social theory are reviewed with an emphasis on why and how the concept of culture is important. The Western medical bias of psychiatric illness needs to be faced as well as the problem of cultural relativism. The paper discusses the heuristic usefulness of a concept of human behavioral breakdowns. The many ways in which culture influences knowledge and practice of biomedical psychiatry are examined critically. The scope of a social theory of the psychiatric is also outlined.
一种将现象视为精神疾病的医学理论会依赖于相关概念,并寻求与生物医学关注点相关的解释。一种关于精神疾病的社会理论则需要相关概念,并寻求与社会和文化科学关注点相关的解释。本文回顾了这种社会理论的一些要求,重点在于文化概念为何重要以及如何重要。精神疾病的西方医学偏见以及文化相对主义问题都需要面对。本文讨论了人类行为崩溃概念的启发式作用。批判性地审视了文化影响生物医学精神病学知识与实践的多种方式。还概述了精神疾病社会理论的范畴。