Baron Todd H, Kimery Brenda D, Sorbi Darius, Gorkis Linda C, Leighton Jonathan A, Fleischer David E
Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Mayo Foundation, Scottsdale, Arizona, USA.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2004 Feb;2(2):178-82. doi: 10.1016/s1542-3565(03)00317-3.
Since Medicare approval for reimbursement of screening colonoscopies, the number of colonoscopy requests has increased. Physician resources have often been inadequate to meet the demand. We sought to reduce the demand for colonoscopy in an open endoscopy system by using a guideline-based triage system to eliminate inappropriate procedures and to align the timing of surveillance colonoscopies with recommendations made by national organizations.
This was a cohort study with primary care outpatients. From October 2002 to February 2003, 498 consecutive patients on a waiting list of 2400 awaiting colonoscopy for all indications were triaged and are the focus of the study. Selection of patients for appropriate colonoscopy was based on consensus guidelines developed for institutional use by using established published guidelines for appropriate colonoscopy indications.
Of the 498 consecutive patients triaged, 139 (28%) were deemed inappropriate. The most common reason was inappropriate referral for surveillance of colorectal polyps. The percentage of inappropriate referrals by the 3 largest referring specialties (internal medicine, family medicine, and gastroenterology) combined was also 28% with no statistically significant differences between specialties.
Most referrals for colonoscopy in an open-access endoscopy system were appropriate, although about 1 in 4 were not. Use of triage and further education of physicians regarding colonoscopy may optimize colonoscopy utilization.
自医疗保险批准报销筛查性结肠镜检查费用以来,结肠镜检查申请数量有所增加。医生资源往往不足以满足需求。我们试图通过使用基于指南的分诊系统,在开放式内镜检查系统中减少结肠镜检查需求,以消除不适当的检查程序,并使监测性结肠镜检查的时间安排与国家组织的建议保持一致。
这是一项针对初级保健门诊患者的队列研究。2002年10月至2003年2月,对2400名因各种适应证等待结肠镜检查的候诊名单上的498例连续患者进行了分诊,这些患者是研究的重点。根据已发表的适当结肠镜检查适应证指南,制定机构使用的共识指南,以此来选择适合进行结肠镜检查的患者。
在498例连续分诊的患者中,139例(28%)被认为不适合。最常见的原因是对结直肠息肉监测的转诊不适当。3个最大转诊专科(内科、家庭医学和胃肠病学)联合转诊的不适当比例也为28%,各专科之间无统计学显著差异。
在开放式内镜检查系统中,大多数结肠镜检查转诊是合适的,尽管约四分之一不合适。使用分诊以及对医生进行关于结肠镜检查的进一步教育可能会优化结肠镜检查的利用。