Gracies Jean-Michel
Department of Neurology, The Mount Sinai Medical Center, New York, New York 10029-6574, USA.
Mov Disord. 2004 Mar;19 Suppl 8:S120-8. doi: 10.1002/mds.20065.
There is considerable evidence that injection of botulinum toxin (BTX) into muscles with spastic overactivity reduces resistance to passive movement in joints supplied by the injected muscles. The demonstration of improvement in active performance of the paretic limbs has been only anecdotal to date, and represents the most difficult challenge in research on BTX therapy in spastic paralysis. Data are reviewed that indicate several neurophysiological actions of BTX, other than the blocking of acetylcholine release at the neuromuscular ending: effects on the central nervous system, including retrograde axonal transport, reduced motoneuronal excitability, action on central synapses such as decreased Renshaw inhibition and increased presynaptic inhibition; action on gamma motoneuronal endings; action on most active terminals; spread of BTX to neighboring muscles; spread of BTX effects to remote muscles. Several of these neurophysiological actions are likely to contribute to improvement in active movements, as they may antagonize the primary mechanisms of functional impairment in patients with spastic paralysis: weakness, spastic cocontraction, spastic dystonia, and muscle shortening. We review the evidence for reduction of spastic cocontraction in both the injected muscle and its antagonist, and for improvement of antagonist weakness after BTX injection. The capacity of intramuscular BTX to reduce spastic dystonia and lengthen shortened muscles is also discussed based on prior literature. When injected into the more overactive of a pair of spastic antagonists around a joint, BTX should affect all the main mechanisms impairing active function around the joint.
有大量证据表明,向过度痉挛的肌肉注射肉毒杆菌毒素(BTX)可降低由注射肌肉所支配关节的被动运动阻力。迄今为止,关于偏瘫肢体主动运动表现改善的证明仅为个案报道,这也是BTX治疗痉挛性麻痹研究中最具挑战性的难题。本文回顾了相关数据,这些数据表明BTX除了在神经肌肉接头处阻断乙酰胆碱释放外,还具有多种神经生理作用:对中枢神经系统的影响,包括逆行轴突运输、降低运动神经元兴奋性、对中枢突触的作用(如减少闰绍抑制和增加突触前抑制);对γ运动神经元末梢的作用;对最活跃终末的作用;BTX向邻近肌肉的扩散;BTX作用向远处肌肉的扩散。这些神经生理作用中的几种可能有助于改善主动运动,因为它们可能对抗痉挛性麻痹患者功能障碍的主要机制:无力、痉挛性共同收缩、痉挛性肌张力障碍和肌肉缩短。我们回顾了关于BTX注射后注射肌肉及其拮抗肌痉挛性共同收缩减少以及拮抗肌无力改善的证据。还根据既往文献讨论了肌肉内注射BTX减轻痉挛性肌张力障碍和延长缩短肌肉的能力。当将BTX注射到关节周围一对痉挛性拮抗肌中较活跃的肌肉时,BTX应能影响关节周围损害主动功能的所有主要机制。