Rajput Alexander, Robinson Christopher A, Rajput Ali H
Division of Neurology, University of Saskatchewan and Saskatoon Health Region, Saskatchewan, Canada.
Neurology. 2004 Mar 23;62(6):932-6. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000115145.18830.1a.
To correlate autopsy findings with the clinical course and disability profile in clinically diagnosed longitudinally followed autopsied essential tremor (ET) patients.
All ET patients followed by one neurologist between 1970 and 2001 who came to autopsy were included. Clinical features and disability were recorded prospectively. Autopsy studies were performed by a qualified neuropathologist.
Twenty cases (10 men and 10 women) had ET onset between childhood and age 68 (median 46.5 years). Six cases had additional features of Parkinson syndrome (PS), with presence of bradykinesia, rigidity, and rest tremor (RT). These included progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP; n = 2), drug-induced parkinsonism (n = 2), idiopathic Parkinson disease (PD; n = 1), and basal ganglia status cribrosus (n = 1). Of the remaining 14 ET cases, 6 had additional RT but no bradykinesia or rigidity. Ten of these 14 (71%) reported physical disability. Eleven of the 14 (79%) had only upper limb (UL) tremor at onset, and 8 of these 11 (73%) had subsequent cranial extension of tremor. Two patients clinically had mild cerebellar ataxia but no cerebellar histologic abnormality. There was no consistent brain pathology in the ET or ET + RT cases.
UL tremor was the most common onset, which often progressed to the cranial musculature. Functional disability and psychological distress were common in these patients. Functional disability was related to the UL tremor. Six of 20 (30%) had additional features of PS. Six of the remaining 14 (43%) had ET and RT; there was no identifiable pathology in these cases. The risk of PD in ET cases was comparable with that in the general population. PSP in two cases was incidental comorbidity.
将经临床诊断并长期随访的尸检确诊特发性震颤(ET)患者的尸检结果与临床病程及残疾状况相关联。
纳入1970年至2001年间由一名神经科医生随访并进行尸检的所有ET患者。前瞻性记录临床特征和残疾情况。由一名合格的神经病理学家进行尸检研究。
20例患者(10名男性和10名女性)ET起病于儿童期至68岁之间(中位年龄46.5岁)。6例具有帕金森综合征(PS)的额外特征,存在运动迟缓、僵硬和静止性震颤(RT)。其中包括进行性核上性麻痹(PSP;n = 2)、药物性帕金森综合征(n = 2)、特发性帕金森病(PD;n = 1)和基底节筛状变性(n = 1)。在其余14例ET病例中,6例有额外的RT,但无运动迟缓或僵硬。这14例中的10例(71%)报告有身体残疾。14例中的11例(79%)起病时仅有上肢(UL)震颤,其中11例中的8例(73%)随后震颤扩展至头部。2例患者临床有轻度小脑共济失调,但小脑组织学无异常。ET或ET + RT病例中无一致的脑病理学改变。
上肢震颤是最常见的起病形式,常进展至头部肌肉组织。功能残疾和心理困扰在这些患者中很常见。功能残疾与上肢震颤有关。20例中的6例(30%)有PS的额外特征。其余14例中的6例(43%)有ET和RT;这些病例中未发现可识别的病理学改变。ET病例中PD的风险与一般人群相当。2例PSP为偶然合并症。