Elble Rodger J
Department of Neurology, Southern Illinois University School of Medicine, Springfield, IL, USA.
J Clin Neurol. 2022 Mar;18(2):127-139. doi: 10.3988/jcn.2022.18.2.127.
Essential tremor (ET) plus is a new tremor classification that was introduced in 2018 by a task force of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society. Patients with ET plus meet the criteria for ET but have one or more additional systemic or neurologic signs of uncertain significance or relevance to tremor ("soft signs"). Soft signs are not sufficient to diagnose another tremor syndrome or movement disorder, and soft signs in ET plus are known to have poor interrater reliability and low diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. Therefore, the clinical significance of ET plus must be interpreted probabilistically when judging whether a patient is more likely to have ET or a combined tremor syndrome, such as dystonic tremor. Such a probabilistic interpretation is possible with Bayesian analysis. This review presents a Bayesian analysis of ET plus in patients suspected of having ET versus a dystonic tremor syndrome, which is the most common differential diagnosis in patients referred for ET. Bayesian analysis of soft signs provides an estimate of the probability that a patient with possible ET is more likely to have an alternative diagnosis. ET plus is a distinct tremor classification and should not be viewed as a subtype of ET. ET plus covers a more-comprehensive phenotyping of people with possible ET, and the clinical interpretation of ET plus is enhanced with Bayesian analysis of associated soft signs.
叠加性特发性震颤(ET plus)是国际帕金森和运动障碍协会的一个特别工作组于2018年引入的一种新的震颤分类。ET plus患者符合ET的标准,但有一个或多个其他意义或与震颤相关性不确定的全身或神经系统体征(“软体征”)。软体征不足以诊断另一种震颤综合征或运动障碍,并且已知ET plus中的软体征在不同评估者之间的可靠性较差,诊断敏感性和特异性较低。因此,在判断患者更可能患有ET还是合并震颤综合征(如肌张力障碍性震颤)时,必须对ET plus的临床意义进行概率性解释。通过贝叶斯分析可以进行这种概率性解释。本综述对疑似患有ET的患者与肌张力障碍性震颤综合征(这是转诊至ET门诊患者最常见的鉴别诊断)进行了ET plus的贝叶斯分析。对软体征的贝叶斯分析提供了一个估计,即可能患有ET的患者更可能有其他诊断的概率。ET plus是一种独特的震颤分类,不应被视为ET的一个亚型。ET plus涵盖了可能患有ET的人群更全面的表型特征,并且通过对相关软体征的贝叶斯分析增强了对ET plus的临床解释。