Savage Van M
Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, NM 87501, USA.
J Theor Biol. 2004 Apr 21;227(4):525-34. doi: 10.1016/j.jtbi.2003.11.030.
Historically, allometric equations relate organismal traits, such as metabolic rate, individual growth rate, and lifespan, to body mass. Similarly, Boltzmann or Q(10) factors are used to relate many organismal traits to body temperature. Allometric equations and Boltzmann factors are being applied increasingly to higher levels of biological organization in an attempt to describe aggregate properties of populations and ecosystems. They have been used previously for studies that analyse scaling relationships between populations and across latitudinal gradients. For these kinds of applications, it is crucial to be aware of the "fallacy of the averages", and it is often problematic or incorrect to simply substitute the average body mass or temperature for an entire population or ecosystem into allometric equations. We derive improved approximations to allometric equations and Boltzmann factors in terms of the central moments of body size and temperature, and we provide tests for the accuracy of these approximations. This framework is necessary for interpreting the predictions of scaling theories for large-scale systems and grants insight into which characteristics of a given distribution are important. These approximations and tests are applied to data for body size for several taxonomic groups, including groups with multiple species, and to data for temperature at locations of varying latitude, corresponding to ectothermic body temperatures. Based on these results, the accuracy and utility of these approximations as applied to biological systems are assessed. We conclude that approximations to allometric equations at the species level are extremely accurate. However, for systems with a large range in body size, evaluating the skewness and kurtosis is often necessary, so it may be advantageous to calculate the exact form for the averaged scaling relationships instead. Moreover, the improved approximation for the Boltzmann factor, which uses the average and standard deviation of temperature, is quite accurate and represents a significant improvement over previous approximations.
从历史上看,异速生长方程将生物体的特征,如代谢率、个体生长率和寿命,与体重联系起来。同样,玻尔兹曼因子或Q(10)因子用于将许多生物体特征与体温联系起来。异速生长方程和玻尔兹曼因子正越来越多地应用于更高层次的生物组织,试图描述种群和生态系统的总体属性。它们之前已被用于分析种群之间以及跨纬度梯度的尺度关系的研究。对于这类应用,意识到“平均值的谬误”至关重要,将整个种群或生态系统的平均体重或温度简单代入异速生长方程往往是有问题的或不正确的。我们根据体型和温度的中心矩推导出异速生长方程和玻尔兹曼因子的改进近似值,并对这些近似值的准确性进行检验。这个框架对于解释大规模系统的尺度理论预测是必要的,并且能深入了解给定分布的哪些特征是重要的。这些近似值和检验应用于几个分类群的体型数据,包括具有多个物种的类群,以及不同纬度位置的温度数据,这些温度对应于变温动物的体温。基于这些结果,评估了这些近似值应用于生物系统时的准确性和实用性。我们得出结论,物种水平上异速生长方程的近似值极其准确。然而,对于体型范围较大的系统,通常有必要评估偏度和峰度,因此计算平均尺度关系的精确形式可能更有利。此外,使用温度平均值和标准差的玻尔兹曼因子的改进近似值相当准确,并且比以前的近似值有显著改进。