Pitzen T R, Zenner S, Barbier D, Georg T, Steudel W I
Neurochirurgische Klinik, Universitätsklinik des Saarlandes, 66421 Homburg, Germany.
Eur Spine J. 2004 Oct;13(6):524-9. doi: 10.1007/s00586-004-0685-5. Epub 2004 Mar 27.
The objective of the study was to investigate the influence of bone cement, length of burr hole and bone density on pullout force and insertional screw torque of cervical spine facet screws. Both facets of 24 human cervical vertebrae were scanned for bone mineral density (BMD) and assigned to two groups for measuring of insertional screw torque and pullout strength. Maximal insertional screw torque was measured and removal of the screws was performed in displacement control (0.25 mm/s) without bone cement (PMMA), with 0.1 ml of PMMA and with the burr hole completely filled with PMMA. Screw torque was 59.1 N cm (+/-25.7 N cm), pullout force was 382.8 N (+/-140.5 N) without PMMA. Injection of 0.1 ml PMMA did not change significantly both screw torque (p=0.73) and pullout (p=0.129). Filling of the burr holes with PMMA increased significantly both screw torque (p<0.0001) and pullout force (p=0.028) when compared with injection of 0.1 ml of PMMA. A positive, moderate correlation was seen between BMD and screw torque before (r=0.501; p=0.097) and after filling with PMMA (r=0.514; p=0.088), BMD and pullout force before (r=0.441; p=0.152) and after complete filling with PMMA (r=0.673; p=0.047). The PMMA does increase both screw torque (p<0.0001) and pullout force (p=0.028) of facet screws significantly if the burr hole is filled with PMMA completely when compared with injection of 0.1 ml PMMA. Bone mineral density of the cervical facets moderately correlates with peak insertional torque and pullout force. This is true for a facet without PMMA and for a facet filled with PMMA. The length of the burr hole seems to be less important.
本研究的目的是调查骨水泥、钻孔长度和骨密度对颈椎小关节螺钉拔出力和拧入螺钉扭矩的影响。对24个人类颈椎的双侧小关节进行骨矿物质密度(BMD)扫描,并分为两组以测量拧入螺钉扭矩和拔出强度。测量最大拧入螺钉扭矩,并在无骨水泥(聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯,PMMA)、注入0.1 ml PMMA以及钻孔完全充满PMMA的情况下,以位移控制(0.25 mm/s)方式取出螺钉。无PMMA时,螺钉扭矩为59.1 N·cm(±25.7 N·cm),拔出力为382.8 N(±140.5 N)。注入0.1 ml PMMA后,螺钉扭矩(p = 0.73)和拔出力(p = 0.129)均无显著变化。与注入0.1 ml PMMA相比,用PMMA填充钻孔可显著增加螺钉扭矩(p < 0.0001)和拔出力(p = 0.028)。在填充PMMA之前(r = 0.501;p = 0.097)和之后(r = 0.514;p = 0.088),BMD与螺钉扭矩之间以及在填充PMMA之前(r = 0.441;p = 0.152)和完全填充PMMA之后(r = 0.673;p = 0.047),BMD与拔出力之间均存在正的中度相关性。与注入0.1 ml PMMA相比,如果钻孔完全用PMMA填充,PMMA确实会显著增加小关节螺钉的螺钉扭矩(p < 0.0001)和拔出力(p = 0.028)。颈椎小关节的骨矿物质密度与峰值拧入扭矩和拔出力呈中度相关。对于未使用PMMA的小关节和填充有PMMA的小关节均如此。钻孔长度似乎不太重要。