Hugate Ronald, Pennypacker Jason, Saunders Marnie, Juliano Paul
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, Pennsylvania State University College of Medicine, Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, 500 University Drive, Hershey, PA 17033, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004 Apr;86(4):794-801. doi: 10.2106/00004623-200404000-00019.
The use of corticosteroid injections in the treatment of retrocalcaneal bursitis is controversial. We assessed the effects of corticosteroid injections, both within the tendon substance and into the retrocalcaneal bursa, on the biomechanical properties of rabbit Achilles tendons. The systemic effects of bilateral corticosteroid injections were also studied.
The rabbits were divided into three treatment groups. The rabbits in Group I received injections of corticosteroid into the Achilles tendon on the left side and injections of normal saline solution into the Achilles tendon on the right, those in Group II received injections of corticosteroid into the retrocalcaneal bursa on the left side and injections of saline solution into the Achilles tendon on the right, and those in Group III received injections of corticosteroid into the Achilles tendon on the left side and injections of corticosteroid into the retrocalcaneal bursa on the right. These injections were given weekly for three weeks. At four weeks after the final injection, the tendons were harvested and were tested biomechanically to determine failure load, midsubstance strain and total strain, modulus of elasticity, failure stress, and total energy absorbed. The site of failure was also documented. The groups were compared according to the location of the injections, the type of injection (steroid or saline solution), and the total systemic load of steroid.
Specimens from limbs that had received intratendinous injections of corticosteroid showed significantly decreased failure stress compared with those from limbs that had received intratendinous injections of saline solution (p = 0.008). Specimens from limbs that had received intrabursal injections of corticosteroid demonstrated significantly decreased failure stress (p = 0.05), significantly decreased total energy absorbed (p = 0.017), and significantly increased total strain (p = 0.049) compared with specimens from limbs that had received intratendinous injections of saline solution. Specimens from limbs that had received intratendinous injections of corticosteroid were biomechanically equivalent to specimens from limbs that had received intrabursal injections of corticosteroid. Specimens from rabbits that had received bilateral injections of corticosteroid demonstrated significantly decreased failure load (p = 0.011), modulus of elasticity (p = 0.015), failure stress (p = 0.03), and total energy absorbed (p = 0.015) compared with those from rabbits that had received unilateral injections of steroid.
Local injections of corticosteroid, both within the tendon substance and into the retrocalcaneal bursa, adversely affected the biomechanical properties of rabbit Achilles tendons. Additionally, tendons from rabbits that had received bilateral injections of corticosteroid demonstrated an additive adverse effect, with significantly worse biomechanical properties compared with tendons from rabbits that had received unilateral injections of corticosteroid.
皮质类固醇注射用于治疗跟腱后囊炎存在争议。我们评估了在肌腱实质内和跟腱后囊内注射皮质类固醇对兔跟腱生物力学特性的影响。还研究了双侧皮质类固醇注射的全身效应。
将兔子分为三个治疗组。第一组兔子左侧跟腱注射皮质类固醇,右侧跟腱注射生理盐水;第二组兔子左侧跟腱后囊注射皮质类固醇,右侧跟腱注射生理盐水;第三组兔子左侧跟腱注射皮质类固醇,右侧跟腱后囊注射皮质类固醇。每周注射一次,共注射三周。最后一次注射四周后,取出肌腱并进行生物力学测试,以确定破坏负荷、肌腱中段应变和总应变、弹性模量、破坏应力以及吸收的总能量。还记录了破坏部位。根据注射部位、注射类型(类固醇或生理盐水)以及类固醇的全身总负荷对各组进行比较。
与接受肌腱内注射生理盐水的肢体标本相比,接受肌腱内注射皮质类固醇的肢体标本的破坏应力显著降低(p = 0.008)。与接受肌腱内注射生理盐水的肢体标本相比,接受滑囊内注射皮质类固醇的肢体标本的破坏应力显著降低(p = 0.05),吸收的总能量显著降低(p = 0.017),总应变显著增加(p = 0.049)。接受肌腱内注射皮质类固醇的肢体标本在生物力学上与接受滑囊内注射皮质类固醇的肢体标本相当。与接受单侧注射类固醇的兔子的标本相比,接受双侧注射皮质类固醇的兔子的标本的破坏负荷显著降低(p = 0.011)、弹性模量显著降低(p = 0.015)、破坏应力显著降低(p = 0.03)以及吸收的总能量显著降低(p = 0.015)。
在肌腱实质内和跟腱后囊内局部注射皮质类固醇对兔跟腱的生物力学特性有不利影响。此外,接受双侧注射皮质类固醇的兔子的肌腱表现出累加的不利影响,与接受单侧注射皮质类固醇的兔子的肌腱相比,其生物力学特性明显更差。