Shavers Vickie L, Brown Martin, Klabunde Carrie N, Potosky Arnold L, Davis William, Moul Judd, Fahey Angela
Applied Research Program, Health Services and Economics Branch, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD 20892-7344, USA.
Med Care. 2004 Mar;42(3):239-50. doi: 10.1097/01.mlr.0000117361.61444.71.
Previous studies have found that racial/ethnic minority patients with prostate cancer are more frequently managed with "watchful waiting." Little, however, is known about the medical care received among men managed with watchful waiting. We examine the type and intensity of medical monitoring received by African American, Hispanic, and white patients with prostate cancer managed with "watchful waiting" in fee-for-service systems.
Surveillance Epidemiology and End Results-Medicare data for men diagnosed with prostate cancer 1994-1996 were used in this study. Men were determined to have initially received watchful waiting if they did not receive surgery, radiation, or hormone treatment within the first 7 months of diagnosis. Crosstabulations, multivariate logistic, and Cox regressions were used to examine the association between clinical and sociodemographic variables and the receipt of a primary care, urology visit, prostate-specific antigen test, or bone scan.
In general, Hispanic and African American men received less medical monitoring and had longer median times from diagnosis to receipt of a medical monitoring visit or procedure than white men. Furthermore, nearly 6% of African American, 5% of Hispanic, and 1% of white men did not have any medical monitoring visits or procedures during the 60-month follow-up period (P<0.001). Differences in observed clinical or sociodemographic characteristics did not explain variations in medical monitoring.
Regular medical monitoring is considered by most medical authorities to be a necessary component of management with watchful waiting. The disproportionately low receipt of medical monitoring visits and procedures observed for African American and Hispanic men managed with watchful waiting in this study suggest that there are racial/ethnic disparities in the receipt of appropriate prostate cancer management.
先前的研究发现,患有前列腺癌的少数族裔患者更常采用“观察等待”的治疗方式。然而,对于采用观察等待治疗的男性所接受的医疗护理情况,人们了解甚少。我们研究了在按服务收费系统中,接受“观察等待”治疗的非裔美国、西班牙裔和白人前列腺癌患者所接受的医疗监测类型和强度。
本研究使用了1994 - 1996年被诊断为前列腺癌的男性的监测、流行病学和最终结果 - 医疗保险数据。如果男性在诊断后的前7个月内未接受手术、放疗或激素治疗,则确定其最初接受了观察等待治疗。使用交叉表、多变量逻辑回归和Cox回归来检验临床和社会人口统计学变量与接受初级保健、泌尿科就诊、前列腺特异性抗原检测或骨扫描之间的关联。
总体而言,西班牙裔和非裔美国男性接受的医疗监测较少,从诊断到接受医疗监测就诊或检查的中位时间比白人男性更长。此外,在60个月的随访期内,近6%的非裔美国男性、5%的西班牙裔男性和1%的白人男性没有任何医疗监测就诊或检查(P<0.001)。观察到的临床或社会人口统计学特征差异并不能解释医疗监测的差异。
大多数医学权威认为定期医疗监测是观察等待治疗管理的必要组成部分。本研究中观察到,接受观察等待治疗的非裔美国和西班牙裔男性接受医疗监测就诊和检查的比例极低,这表明在接受适当的前列腺癌管理方面存在种族/族裔差异。