Hara Y, Kohri K, Takada M, Kodama M, Ishikawa Y, Kurita T
Department of Urology, Kinki University School of Medicine.
Nihon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi. 1992 Jul;83(7):1124-9. doi: 10.5980/jpnjurol1989.83.1124.
Nine hundred and fifty cases with renal and ureteral stones were treated by extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) with Siements Lithostar unit from September, 1988 to October, 1990 at Kinki University Hospital. ESWL treatments were performed twice or more on 110 cases (DIFFICULTY GROUP). Ninety-seven cases who were cured by only one ESWL treatment were selected randomly as the control group. The two groups were retrospectively compared to study the factors requiring more than two times of ESWL treatments. There was a significant difference in the time of spontaneous stone discharge before ESWL treatment, the degree of hydronephrosis and the incidence of staghorn calculi as well as middle-lower ureteral calculi between the two groups. There was not a significant difference but a tendency to a longer period of stone existing at the same position and a higher percentage of past history of percutaneous nephrolithotropsy (PNL) in DIFFICULTY GROUP. Because ESWL monotherapy is considered to have limitations, auxiliary procedures or other treatments such as PNL and transurethral lithotripsy are recommended for patients in who in the stones were poorly disintegrated by the first ESWL treatment.
1988年9月至1990年10月,在近畿大学医院,使用西门子Lithostar设备,对950例肾和输尿管结石患者进行了体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL)治疗。对110例患者(困难组)进行了两次或更多次的ESWL治疗。随机选择97例仅接受一次ESWL治疗即治愈的患者作为对照组。对两组进行回顾性比较,以研究需要进行两次以上ESWL治疗的因素。两组在ESWL治疗前结石自然排出时间、肾积水程度、鹿角形结石以及输尿管中下段结石的发生率方面存在显著差异。困难组在结石在同一位置存在的时间较长以及经皮肾镜取石术(PNL)既往史的百分比方面虽无显著差异,但有这种趋势。由于认为ESWL单一疗法存在局限性,对于首次ESWL治疗结石破碎不佳的患者,建议采用辅助手术或其他治疗方法,如PNL和经尿道碎石术。