Moreno C, Cuesta-Herranz J, Fernández-Távora L, Alvarez-Cuesta E
Allergy Department, Hospital Reina Sofia, Cordoba, Spain.
Clin Exp Allergy. 2004 Apr;34(4):527-31. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.2004.1819.x.
The fear of side-effects has led to strict regulations preventing a more widespread use of specific immunotherapy (SIT) in some countries, in spite of the low risk of systemic reactions (SRs) reported in well-controlled studies. The goal of the study was to carry out a prospective and multi-centric trial to evaluate the safety, risk factors and compliance degree of commercially available SIT.
The study was carried out in 14 allergy departments from Spain. Four-hundred and eighty-eight patients with rhinitis and/or asthma were submitted to treatment with biologically standardized allergen extracts commercially available. They were administered following the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology guidelines.
Four hundred and twenty-three patients (86.7%) completed the treatment and remained under control at the end of the trial. Out of 17,526 administered doses, 17,368 doses (99.1%) were not associated with a reaction. Eighteen patients (3.7%) experienced 53 (0.3% of the doses) SRs. All immediate SRs were mild or moderate and responded well to ordinary treatment measures. There were no fatal reactions, anaphylactic shock or life-threatening reactions. A higher ratio of SRs was found among asthmatic and dust mite allergic patients, although multi-variable logistic analysis did not demonstrate any risk factor associated with SRs. There was also a subgroup of patients at risk for recurrent reactions, and therefore 40% of SRs had been avoided if the maximal number of SRs had been previously limited to only three SRs.
This multi-centric study showed that SIT was a safe treatment with a very good compliance. Future guidelines of SIT should limit the maximal number of SRs.
尽管在严格控制的研究中报告的全身反应(SRs)风险较低,但对副作用的担忧导致一些国家出台了严格的规定,限制了特异性免疫疗法(SIT)的更广泛应用。本研究的目的是开展一项前瞻性多中心试验,以评估市售SIT的安全性、风险因素和依从程度。
该研究在西班牙的14个过敏科进行。488例鼻炎和/或哮喘患者接受了市售生物标准化变应原提取物的治疗。治疗遵循欧洲变态反应和临床免疫学会指南进行。
423例患者(86.7%)完成了治疗,试验结束时病情得到控制。在17526剂给药中,17368剂(99.1%)未发生反应。18例患者(3.7%)出现了53次SRs(占给药剂量的0.3%)。所有即刻SRs均为轻度或中度,对常规治疗措施反应良好。未发生致命反应、过敏性休克或危及生命的反应。在哮喘患者和尘螨过敏患者中发现SRs的比例较高,尽管多变量逻辑分析未显示与SRs相关的任何风险因素。也有一部分患者有反复发生反应的风险,因此,如果之前将SRs的最大数量限制在仅3次,则可避免40%的SRs。
这项多中心研究表明,SIT是一种安全的治疗方法,依从性非常好。未来的SIT指南应限制SRs的最大数量。