Antoszewski J, Redfern D, Faraone L, Meyer J R, Vurgaftman I, Lindemuth J
Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2004 Mar;69(3 Pt 2):038701; author reply 038702. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.69.038701. Epub 2004 Mar 11.
We point out that the comparison in Fig. 1 of the recent publication by S. Kiatgamolchai et al. [Phys. Rev. E 66, 036705 (2002)] of the proposed maximum entropy-mobility spectrum analysis (ME-MSA) with our quantitative mobility spectrum analysis (QMSA) is misleading. Rather than comparing with the more recent "improved" version of QMSA [Vurgaftman et al., J. Appl. Phys. 84, 4966 (1998)], a preliminary version that was three years older and demonstrably inferior was employed. We show that ME-MSA and the improved QMSA give quite similar results.
我们指出，S. Kiatgamolchai等人近期发表在[《物理评论E》66, 036705 (2002)]上的论文中图1里，将所提出的最大熵迁移率谱分析（ME-MSA）与我们的定量迁移率谱分析（QMSA）进行的比较具有误导性。他们采用的不是与QMSA更新的“改进”版本[Vurgaftman等人，《应用物理杂志》84, 4966 (1998)]进行比较，而是采用了早三年且明显较差的初步版本。我们表明，ME-MSA和改进后的QMSA给出的结果非常相似。
