Performance analysis of molecularly imprinted polymers for carboxylate and aminophosphate templates using commercially available basic functional monomers.

A survey of commercially available amine-based monomers for binding and selectivity of carboxylate and phosphonic acid templates has revealed that the best selectivity is found for the pyridine-based monomers, while the highest affinity was found for 2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate (2-DEMA, 1). In fact, a more general finding is that selectivity is higher for aromatic amine-based monomers even though affinity remains higher for aliphatic amine-based monomers. An attempt to combine the optimal properties of these two classes of amine monomers, i.e. 2-vinylpyridine (2-VPY, 2), and 2-DEMA by using both simultaneously in a single imprinted polymer resulted in an MIP whose properties were dominated by the aliphatic amine-based monomer 2-DEMA. A controversy between the two commercially available vinylpyridine monomers, 2-VPY and 4-vinylpyridine (4-VPY, 3), was investigated, revealing that neither monomer is generally better for molecular imprinting; rather, the choice of 2-VPY or 4-VPY is template specific (although the preponderance of data tends to frequently favor 4-VPY). Phosphonic acid templates proved to be less successful as templates for molecular imprinting versus carboxylate functionalized templates, although binding was obtained and shown to be controllable via an ion-exchange process.