Kagolovsky Yuri, Moehr Jochen R
School of Health Information Science, University of Victoria, PO Box 3050, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada V8W 3P5.
J Med Syst. 2004 Feb;28(1):89-101. doi: 10.1023/b:joms.0000021523.23376.e9.
This is the third in the series of the articles on an application of the systems analytic approach to evaluation of information retrieval (IR). Previously terminological and evaluation problems associated with IR were identified, and it was proposed that the systems analytic approach can provide solutions to these problems. Here, after the general discussion of a systems approach, different attempts to introduce this approach into IR are presented and critiqued: modelling of IR, identifying boundaries of a system under evaluation, identifying variables under investigation; and creating evaluation frameworks. On the basis of the critique of this work, the authors present their proposal for a solution: first the IR components, their boundaries and relationships are identified, and then the two models of IR are introduced. One of the models addresses components of the IR process and relationships between them, the second one is the process model of IR.
这是关于系统分析方法应用于信息检索(IR)评估系列文章中的第三篇。之前已识别出与信息检索相关的术语和评估问题,并提出系统分析方法可为这些问题提供解决方案。在此,在对系统方法进行一般性讨论之后,介绍并批判了将该方法引入信息检索的不同尝试:信息检索建模、确定被评估系统的边界、确定所研究的变量以及创建评估框架。基于对这项工作的批判,作者提出了他们的解决方案建议:首先识别信息检索组件、它们的边界和关系,然后引入两种信息检索模型。其中一个模型涉及信息检索过程的组件及其之间的关系,第二个模型是信息检索的过程模型。