Siriwardena D, Edmunds B, Wormald R P L, Khaw P T
Wound Healing Unit, Institute of Ophthalmology and Moorfields Eye Hospital, 11-43 Bath Street, London EC1V 9EL, UK.
Br J Ophthalmol. 2004 Jul;88(7):873-6. doi: 10.1136/bjo.2003.034256.
To assess the pattern of use of antimetabolites in trabeculectomy surgery by all consultant ophthalmologists in the United Kingdom.
A postal questionnaire of 12 questions regarding antimetabolite use in trabeculectomy surgery was sent to all 749 consultant ophthalmologists in the United Kingdom. The consultants were asked to estimate the number of trabeculectomies they performed per year, how often they used 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) in primary and redo surgery, their usual method of administration of 5-FU, how often they used mitomycin (MMC) in primary and redo surgery, and their usual dosage regimen of MMC. Factors that influenced the decision to use or not use antimetabolites were also assessed.
The response rate of consultants returning the questionnaire was 82% (615 out of 749); 87% (533) of these consultants perform trabeculectomy surgery. Of these 533 consultants, 98 (18%) never use an antimetabolite. Most consultants (82%) use antimetabolites, but use them infrequently (only 9% using antimetabolites in more than half their cases). The preferred antimetabolite is 5-FU rather than MMC. Of the 435 consultants performing trabeculectomy surgery and using antimetabolites, 402 (93%) use 5-FU and 179 (41%) use MMC. Various factors influenced the decision to use or not use an antimetabolite, but experience of complications associated with their use was a factor for 34% of consultants.
The use of antimetabolites, particularly MMC, in the United Kingdom is much less than in America or Japan, where trabeculectomy with MMC is the surgical procedure preferred by glaucoma specialists.
评估英国所有眼科顾问医师在小梁切除术手术中使用抗代谢药物的模式。
向英国所有749名眼科顾问医师发送了一份关于小梁切除术手术中抗代谢药物使用情况的包含12个问题的邮政调查问卷。顾问医师们被要求估计他们每年进行的小梁切除术数量、在初次手术和再次手术中使用5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)的频率、他们使用5-FU的常规给药方法、在初次手术和再次手术中使用丝裂霉素(MMC)的频率以及他们使用MMC的常规剂量方案。还评估了影响使用或不使用抗代谢药物决策的因素。
返回问卷的顾问医师的回复率为82%(749名中的615名);其中87%(533名)的顾问医师进行小梁切除术手术。在这533名顾问医师中,98名(18%)从未使用过抗代谢药物。大多数顾问医师(82%)使用抗代谢药物,但使用频率较低(只有9%的人在超过一半的病例中使用抗代谢药物)。首选的抗代谢药物是5-FU而非MMC。在435名进行小梁切除术手术并使用抗代谢药物的顾问医师中,402名(93%)使用5-FU,179名(41%)使用MMC。各种因素影响了使用或不使用抗代谢药物的决策,但使用抗代谢药物相关并发症的经验是34%的顾问医师考虑的一个因素。
在英国,抗代谢药物,尤其是MMC的使用比美国或日本少得多,在美国和日本,使用MMC的小梁切除术是青光眼专家首选的手术方法。